![[dr. bob]](/dr-bob-sm.gif)
Dr. Bob is Robert Hsiung, MD,
bob@dr-bob.orgShown: posts 1 to 25 of 67. This is the beginning of the thread.
Posted by tealady on September 13, 2003, at 17:37:49
In reply to Re: Larry what do you think about lithium orotate? » tealady, posted by Larry Hoover on September 4, 2003, at 9:48:48
Hi Lar,
I've been backing down on the large doses of vits/minerals. Last Sunday ( a week ago) I knew I had too much zinc(probably) or selenium from the metallic taste in my mouth. (gone now)
Don't like to admit I was also sitting at the computer with tears streaming down my face while reading your replies to me. I'm blaming too much something..umm zinc from the picolinate form? Just wanted you to know I did appreciate your replies and have been thinking, was just a bit brain fogged to give reasoned replies to all of them...but I will!The zinc I stopped after that and then selenium the next day, then the magnesium/ascorbate I tapered off..and other multis. I'm getting ready for the blood tests etc.
I tried 2000mg tyrosine on Thursday., and it was too much. My blood pressure increased a little from 120/80 to 135/88. I stayed awake all day! but I did feel it was a bit much. Could feel heartbeat was wrong..too fast. (resting pulse 91 ) I woke up after 5 hrs sleep and didn't feel tired, but my tooth nerve ached., strangely the tyrosine seemed to quiet it., I think..Took another 500mg tyrosine and thyroid med and went back to sleep, woke up in morning with a slightly too much T3 headache(mild tension headache middle of forehead) and eyes stinging and bit glazed...so I've stopped for a while.
Feeling better every day. yesterday and today , feel good and I can even kinda type without correcting spelling 20 times for each word!
There is something strange to my reactions to vitamins/supplements(like tyrosine) that I also feel best for a few days after I stop taking large doses of them. I've heard others say the same of drugs/vitamins..and I don't think the blood level is the answer as taking differing amounts doesn't produce the same effect. I suspect it has something to do with altering different receptor levels /sensitivities while retaining higher amounts of transmitters for a while...or something similar on the cellular level/ion pumps/ATP level. It's beyond me.
Pity it doesn't last! Once everything drops back down and resets, its back to needing them again.
One thing I have noticed about taking tyrosine is it increases my desire for chocolate greatly!!!...similar to PMS times!
So I'm guessing this means there is something missing that is supplied by phenylalanine?
I've bought some l-phenylalanine (couldn't find any dl so far), and I'll try that soon.
I'll have to go back and reread your posts to see if taking both the l-phenyl and the tyrosine together is similar to the dl-phenylalanine? Probably not!T3(thyroid) stimulates appetite, but in most the effect is not great and only last the first few days they begin.
With me(unusually) it is ongoing. Doesn't poop out unfortunately. That is why I tried the tyrosine. I does take an edge off my hunger,. but not enough...sigh. Perhaps the l-phenylalanine will help more?.
What I have found though, is the rebound effect of stopping the tyrosine has increased this appetite stimulation sooo much..I need my lips sown together or something!
Before the T3 , I had zilch appetite, didn't gain too much weight as never ate much.
I thought the appetite gain was good that it allowed me to eat a healthy diet..but the weight gain is ridiculous. My temperature/metabolism is still not high enough I guess. (I'm running about one degree too cold at present.)
I think I'm going to need a appetite suppressing drug soon, if the l-phenyl doesn't work. I can't get my mind off the starving feeling.> I've been using DLPA, but I've just about run out. I've got some tyrosine. I'll let you know.
How did you go?
Hugs, Jan
Posted by Larry Hoover on September 13, 2003, at 18:10:50
In reply to Tyrosine (cont) » Larry Hoover, posted by tealady on September 13, 2003, at 17:37:49
>
> Hi Lar,
> Don't like to admit I was also sitting at the computer with tears streaming down my face while reading your replies to me.Forget all the other stuff for a minute.....why were you crying? I must be psychic or something....I was concerned about you, and you post....boing!
Lar
Posted by tealady on September 13, 2003, at 18:53:26
In reply to Re: Tyrosine (cont) » tealady, posted by Larry Hoover on September 13, 2003, at 18:10:50
Bonk! I knew I shouldn't have posted that <g>.
Guess I just appreciated your support and for some reason was too overemotional, depressed etc.
Not something I'm usually in the habit of, but I guess it just indicates some levels were off.
Jan
Posted by Larry Hoover on September 14, 2003, at 7:20:28
In reply to Re: Tyrosine (cont) » Larry Hoover, posted by tealady on September 13, 2003, at 18:53:26
> Bonk! I knew I shouldn't have posted that <g>.
It was very real. I hope I didn't embarass you by drawing attention to it.
> Guess I just appreciated your support and for some reason was too overemotional, depressed etc.
For some reason? I wondered if that's what you were meaning, but I had no way of knowing. I'm happy to have connected with you, and that's a good thing.
> Not something I'm usually in the habit of, but I guess it just indicates some levels were off.
> JanNo, it was touching.
Lar
P.S. The multiple windows thingie is the result of a new feature Dr. Bob added on. It messed me up, too, because I do multiple edits myself, most of the time. Turns out that there are extra buttons added, way down the "confirm post" page, that let you go back without opening the "error" window. Also, there is a re-edit window on the "confirm post" page that lets you change the text, and move forward to a new "confirm post" page, without going back at all.
Hope that helps.
Lar
Posted by Larry Hoover on September 14, 2003, at 7:57:05
In reply to Tyrosine (cont) » Larry Hoover, posted by tealady on September 13, 2003, at 17:37:49
>
> Hi Lar,
> I've been backing down on the large doses of vits/minerals. Last Sunday ( a week ago) I knew I had too much zinc(probably) or selenium from the metallic taste in my mouth. (gone now)Zinc is a key mineral in the sensitivity of taste buds and the sense of smell. We each have a differing capacity for retention of these minerals, and you're wise to adjust the dose based on responses like that. BTW, bringing a concept in from another of your posts, brazil nuts are probably the most concentrated natural source of selenium, so you should factor them into the mineral equation. (I just tried to find an exact amount of selenium, but it turns out that the selenium content can vary 100-fold depending on the region in which the brazil nuts are grown. :-/ )
> Don't like to admit I was also sitting at the computer with tears streaming down my face while reading your replies to me. I'm blaming too much something..umm zinc from the picolinate form?
Don't overthink it, OK?
>Just wanted you to know I did appreciate your replies and have been thinking, was just a bit brain fogged to give reasoned replies to all of them...but I will!
I'm learning a lot from you, too. This is win-win, methinks.
> The zinc I stopped after that and then selenium the next day, then the magnesium/ascorbate I tapered off..and other multis. I'm getting ready for the blood tests etc.
>
> I tried 2000mg tyrosine on Thursday., and it was too much. My blood pressure increased a little from 120/80 to 135/88. I stayed awake all day! but I did feel it was a bit much. Could feel heartbeat was wrong..too fast. (resting pulse 91 ) I woke up after 5 hrs sleep and didn't feel tired, but my tooth nerve ached., strangely the tyrosine seemed to quiet it., I think..Took another 500mg tyrosine and thyroid med and went back to sleep, woke up in morning with a slightly too much T3 headache(mild tension headache middle of forehead) and eyes stinging and bit glazed...so I've stopped for a while.It doesn't surprise me that tyrosine affected your thyroid function. You will be bound to have to tweak doses a bit, to find a new balance.
> Feeling better every day. yesterday and today , feel good and I can even kinda type without correcting spelling 20 times for each word!That's great.
> There is something strange to my reactions to vitamins/supplements(like tyrosine) that I also feel best for a few days after I stop taking large doses of them. I've heard others say the same of drugs/vitamins..and I don't think the blood level is the answer as taking differing amounts doesn't produce the same effect. I suspect it has something to do with altering different receptor levels /sensitivities while retaining higher amounts of transmitters for a while...or something similar on the cellular level/ion pumps/ATP level. It's beyond me.That's quite a valid explanation. It may also be the sudden absence of inhibition; some enzymes have inhibitors that reduce their activity in the overabundance of a substrate.
My personal supplementation scheduling is pulsatile. Little bursts, driven by intuition. I'm just not constitutionally disposed to routinely consume supplements. I'm too easily distracted, I'm lazy, whatever. I can rationalize it many different ways, but I don't take supps every day. And yet, I obtain substantial benefits from this pattern of behaviour.
I've also had periods where I've supplemented more religiously, and that has worked for me, too. You might consider that to be a comparison between acute treatment vs. chronic (i.e. maintenance therapy). <shrug>
> Pity it doesn't last! Once everything drops back down and resets, its back to needing them again.
Have you tried lower, but intermittent, doses during the "pause" phase?
> One thing I have noticed about taking tyrosine is it increases my desire for chocolate greatly!!!...similar to PMS times!That's intriguing.
> So I'm guessing this means there is something missing that is supplied by phenylalanine?
Phenethylamine (PEA) is in chocolate, and it can be produced in your brain from phenylalanine, but not tyrosine.
> I've bought some l-phenylalanine (couldn't find any dl so far), and I'll try that soon.
> I'll have to go back and reread your posts to see if taking both the l-phenyl and the tyrosine together is similar to the dl-phenylalanine? Probably not!Not. Sorry. The d-isomer of phenylalanine has distinctive effects. Still, I personally believe that even l-phenylalanine is superior to tyrosine for many people, as it has more possible uses to which it can be put, by your body.
> T3(thyroid) stimulates appetite, but in most the effect is not great and only last the first few days they begin.
> With me(unusually) it is ongoing. Doesn't poop out unfortunately. That is why I tried the tyrosine. I does take an edge off my hunger,. but not enough...sigh. Perhaps the l-phenylalanine will help more?.I hope so. I think the d-,l- product would be more likely to block hunger, as it prolongs the half-life of endorphins, the natural brain opiates.
> What I have found though, is the rebound effect of stopping the tyrosine has increased this appetite stimulation sooo much..I need my lips sown together or something!
Can you reduce the T3 a bit, if you try tyrosine again?
> Before the T3 , I had zilch appetite, didn't gain too much weight as never ate much.
That's what I'm thinking, that the T3 effect has been magnified.
> I thought the appetite gain was good that it allowed me to eat a healthy diet..but the weight gain is ridiculous. My temperature/metabolism is still not high enough I guess. (I'm running about one degree too cold at present.)
I'm going to try and figure out if you can reduce the hunger thingie. I'm not sure it's possible. (I had major hunger when I tried Remeron, and I don't think I found anything that was an anorectant.)
> I think I'm going to need a appetite suppressing drug soon, if the l-phenyl doesn't work. I can't get my mind off the starving feeling.
That's brutal, I know.
> > I've been using DLPA, but I've just about run out. I've got some tyrosine. I'll let you know.
> How did you go?
> Hugs, JanI didn't try it, yet.
Hugs to you, sweetie.
Lar
Posted by tealady on September 14, 2003, at 8:38:40
In reply to Re: Tyrosine (cont) » tealady, posted by Larry Hoover on September 14, 2003, at 7:20:28
Thanks Lar,
ahh, I see the buttons!
Thinking on it, I'm sure I was "off" due to the chocolate I consumed the previous day. Always makes me feel great at the timeof consumption and depressed, fatigued the next day..any idea why?
A chococlate addiction!, like I said..made worse by tyrosineJan
Posted by EscherDementian on September 15, 2003, at 16:29:51
In reply to Re: Tyrosine (cont) » Larry Hoover, posted by tealady on September 13, 2003, at 18:53:26
> Bonk! I knew I shouldn't have posted that <g>.
> Guess I just appreciated your support and for some reason was too overemotional, depressed etc.
> Not something I'm usually in the habit of, but I guess it just indicates some levels were off.
> Jan
>...Just a respectful step forward from lurk-mode, here, please forgive if i'm butting into anything personal...
Did it happen on or close to the 3rd September?
Remember, Mars is 'unnaturally' close (to our current biologies).A friend who is a MSW,MA,LCSW, happened to mention that ALL of her clients were having uncommon emotional upheavals that day/night.
So did i. And i know many others who did too.Just a thought,
Escher
Posted by tealady on September 16, 2003, at 21:42:33
In reply to For tealady , posted by EscherDementian on September 15, 2003, at 16:29:51
Escher Hi,
Thanks..what an out!..I'm blaming Mars!
Unfortunately the posts I was reading were made around 5th Sept..just checked. I was fine on the 2nd
Now I did have a filling done on the 4th..a new anesthetic that I haven't researched...and doesn't "take" properly till after the dentist is finished!.. I'm going now to find out how to spell it and research that. The dentist wouldn't use my old faithful one I like..probably didn't have it in stock, but he was the only dentist I could find that used the filling material I wanted.
Jan
Posted by Kacy on September 17, 2003, at 8:17:51
In reply to Re: For tealady » EscherDementian, posted by tealady on September 16, 2003, at 21:42:33
EcherDementian: what filling material did you want. I'm a little confused about what materials are in my teeth and what amalgam actually is–the good one or the bad one. (I've got a lot of fillings.) I'd like to know what to ask for in the future.
Posted by Larry Hoover on September 20, 2003, at 7:20:09
In reply to Re: For tealady » EscherDementian, posted by Kacy on September 17, 2003, at 8:17:51
> EcherDementian: what filling material did you want. I'm a little confused about what materials are in my teeth and what amalgam actually is–the good one or the bad one. (I've got a lot of fillings.) I'd like to know what to ask for in the future.
Amalgam fillings are an alloy of mostly mercury and silver, and their appearance is quite dark once they age a bit (almost black). The problem is that they leach mercury, and mercury is quite toxic.
"Modern" fillings are sometimes called composite fillings, or acrylic fillings, or sometimes just "white fillings". They too have a little bit of a toxicity problem, but it is only for a very brief period, unlike amalgam fillings, which are toxic forever.
Lar
Posted by tealady on September 20, 2003, at 9:06:22
In reply to Re: amalgam » Kacy, posted by Larry Hoover on September 20, 2003, at 7:20:09
Lar,
>Don't overthink it, OK?
Well how's this...I did look up the dental filling, Citanest Plain.
http://www.dentsplypharma.com/Package%20Inserts/Citanest%20PI.pdfIt doesn't sound too good.
My reactions were..not enough numbing..late onset of numbing (not in the PDF)..got tissue numbing 1/4 hr to 3 1/2 hrs after injection. (max level about 1 1/2 hrs after injection)..so didn't work real well
About 4 hrs later..fatigue developing into a migraine for about 3 days(mild)..coming out of this depressed and emotional.
At the time, and the next few days, I thought I was getting asthma as could only take half breaths. I tried deep breathing and found I couldn't do it..would feel I needed more oxygen and start gasping for air, or splutter and wheeze a bit, and also 'tingling' increased....didn't notice any "blueness " though.
But I was taking VitC in large doses ..like 4g 2 times a day, with magnesium..and other vits, and I read the treatment is VitC..so I was wondering if perhaps I do have a mild reaction to methaeglobulin..
I seem to go "reasonable" on xylocaine with o.o1 mg/ml adrenaline (lindocaine)
http://www.dentsplypharma.com/Package%20Inserts/Xylocaine%20PI.pdf
which appears similar...although sometimes get a headache, never as depressed and no trouble breathing, tingling etcBoth Prilocaine and Lidocaine say "
CONTRAINDICATIONS
Prilocaine is contraindicated in patients with a known history of hypersensitivity to local anesthetics of the amide
type and in those rare patients with congenital or idiopathic methemoglobinemia"
-------------------"Hydrolysis of prilocaine by amidases yields ortho-touluidine and N-propylanine. Both of these compounds may undergo ring hydroxylation.
O-toluidine has been found to produce methaemoglobulin"So I tried to see if I could learn anything from this. I tried searching for methaemoglobulin..I did come across a photo of red/blue feet from it..now I get that from B12(hydrocobalamine) , and hands too..used to go a deep purple color and really tingle, with each needle has been lessening in effect..about 2 years now..also a slightly less reaction from Methylcobalamin sublinguals. I've showed this to docs and they never could figure it out...so now I wonder
http://courses.nus.edu.sg/course/patleesh/ha/drugs.htm..except that would be a very washed out photo of my feet..mine went a real deep shade, and hands
So I was wondering where the break was ..and if I could put this to use ..like perhaps taking NADH (as you suggested) might bypass a missing enzyme?http://www.genome.ad.jp/dbget-bin/www_bget?path:hsa00380 Tryptophan metabolism
http://www.genome.ad.jp/dbget-bin/show_pathway?hsa00760+55191 Nicotinate and nicotinamide metabolism - Homo sapiens
http://www.chem.qmul.ac.uk/iubmb/enzyme/EC1/6/2/4.html
IUBMB Enzyme Nomenclature
EC 1.6.2.4
Common name: NADPH-ferrihemoprotein reductaseReaction: NADPH2 + 2 ferricytochrome = NADP + 2 ferrocytochrome
Other name(s): NADP-cytochrome reductase; TPNH2 cytochrome c reductase; ferrihemoprotein P-450 reductase; reductase, cytochrome c (reduced nicotinamide adenine dinucleotide phosphate); NADPH-cytochrome c reductase; TPNH-cytochrome c reductase; dihydroxynicotinamide adenine dinucleotide phosphate-cytochrome c reductase; reduced nicotinamide adenine dinucleotide phosphate-cytochrome c reductase; cytochrome c reductase (reduced nicotinamide adenine dinucleotide phosphate, NADPH, NADPH-dependent); NADPH-cytochrome c oxidoreductase; NADPH-ferricytochrome c oxidoreductase; NADPH-dependent cytochrome c reductase; NADP-cytochrome c reductase; FAD-cytochrome c reductase; NADPH-cytochrome p-450 reductase; aldehyde reductase (NADPH-dependent)
Systematic name: NADPH:ferrihemoprotein oxidoreductase
-----------
I forget now where I got with this..but I couldn't find it in any pathways.
Don't overthink it, OK?>Just wanted you to know I did appreciate your replies and have been thinking, was just a bit brain fogged to give reasoned replies to all of them...but I will!
Not sure on any of this but hey I wouldn't want to give a standard boring excuse.....
Jan
Posted by tealady on September 20, 2003, at 16:59:21
In reply to Re: Tyrosine (cont) » tealady, posted by Larry Hoover on September 14, 2003, at 7:57:05
Lar,
Just an addition to my above post ...on my B12 reactions
my post re tingling and redness
http://forums.about.com/ab-thyroid/messages?msg=28843.5
"did have a B12 and iron injection this month.,as well as an iron injection last month as I should have absorbed more than enough with food and supps.
About 2 hrs after the B12, iron injections this time my hands turned purple(only for the first night) and my "tingling" and "stiffness" in legs,feet and hands has actually increased. I guess I shouldn't be surprised as my friend said- your hands were always purple- but they used to be a light purple-blue from the cold, not a dark purple. At least I'm not frozen any more and my extremities are not purplish -white and frozen since being on thyroid meds.Just wondered if you had heard of any connection between B12 and numbness and tingling"
After each B12 needle I'd have a "one step backwards, two steps forwards reaction"...I was hoping I was doing the right hing, but the trend line seem to be on the improve. Each injection the "purple" lessened and the color of feet/hands turned brighter red
Here's part of a post I did on a PN forum
"My B12 injection last week caused my to be very fatigued and the palms of my hands to go a bright red and my toes and soles of feet - and a headache for about 4 days. It's been 4 months now and I'm still reacting to the hydrocobalamin injections -I'm still hoping this is the b12 fixing something and NOT some allergic type reaction to the hydrocobalamin making something worse."
Each needle the reaction has lessened.
Also methylcobalamin sublinguals have similarbut far weaker reactions.
I haven't taken any large dose B12 for probably 3 months now. I was going to see where my blood levels got to.So how's that rate on originality?
Hugs, Jan
Posted by tealady on September 20, 2003, at 18:16:22
In reply to Re: Tyrosine (cont) » tealady, posted by Larry Hoover on September 14, 2003, at 7:57:05
Lar,
> I've been backing down on the large doses of vits/minerals. Last Sunday ( a week ago) I knew I had too much zinc(probably) or selenium from the metallic taste in my mouth. (gone now)
This was the time I had the filling the previous Friday .
I was mixing magnesium carbonate(light) with ascorbic acid..both in powder form
the adding some water, stirring until clear and fizzing mostly stopped to remove the Co2, and drinking....to get larger doses of magnesium.Couple of questions
- I used about a teaspoon of each usually, mixed together. (tapering off over the days)With equal amounts of each, any idea of what I was swallowing..I know magnesium ascorbate..but some extra ascorbic acid or extra magnesium carbonate..I suspect extra ascrbic acid
-one of the multis I took had magnesium oxide (heavy) in it...besides weight, like the light is a real light fluffy powder..what , if any is the difference between light and heavy. I can't find this out anywhere. Just curious, no real need to knowAlso I was taking this form of VitC around the time of the injection..from a few hours before the dental visit to a few days after in large doses.
I was thinking if when they say VitC is a treatment..do they mean pure ascorbic acid or would magnesium ascorbate achieve the same effect
..I'm still confused over acidity stuff..As always I value your help,
Hugs, Jan
Posted by tealady on September 20, 2003, at 18:54:35
In reply to Re: amalgam » Larry Hoover, posted by tealady on September 20, 2003, at 9:06:22
Just wanted to add this to the post..forgot it!
This was the enzyme I was looking for in the pathways that I couldn't find.But I could be barking up the wrong tree.
Methemoglobinemia; a description of a case of NADH methemoglobulin reductase deficiency
http://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/entrez/query.fcgi?cmd=Retrieve&db=PubMed&list_uids=7254639&dopt=Abstract&itool=iconabstrI'm hoping NADH may be able to bypass it..well a little hope?
Not even sure this is what is happening..just grasping for an answer
Jan
Posted by tealady on September 20, 2003, at 19:46:15
In reply to Re: For tealady » EscherDementian, posted by Kacy on September 17, 2003, at 8:17:51
Kacy,
The silver stuff is called amalgam..it contains about 50% mercury..heard of "the mad hatter"
http://www.ithyroid.com/mercury.htm
At least I always fought not to get it put in my kdids mouths. It has been banned in many European countries I think. It s what a lot of dentists still use over here for back teeth.I had Biodent Diamond Crown..I know it is available in Canada and New Zealand. I have not heard of a anyone in the US using it. Unfortunately it doesn't last any longer than normal composites despite the hype..but it has no fluoride, other junk or taste. Of course there is also the bonding material to consider..I didn't go into that ..most dentists think I'm obsessive enough already!
http://www.biodent.com.au/http://www.cda-adc.ca/jcda/vol-64/issue-8/561.html
One day, I am going to have to get cerec for a few teeth..this is very exxy..but the only alternative to amalgam in huge fillings..like that go beneath the gum line and make up mmost of the tooth. Either hthat is getting my teeth pulled out I guess..had one done that way already.
http://www.yoursmile.net.au/albumcerec.html
http://www.thedentist.co.nz/cosmetic.htmlI have an autoimmune problem
http://www.thyroid-info.com/autoimmune/mercury.htmHope this helps,
Jan
Posted by tealady on September 21, 2003, at 5:14:39
In reply to Re: amalgam » Larry Hoover, posted by tealady on September 20, 2003, at 9:06:22
Hi Lar,
Me again!
(I've outworn my welcome even with myself!)I was thinking I probably don't even have any problem with NADH methemoglobulin reductase ..as I used to go a deep purple/red after B12 needles (hands and feet), and feet, hands and lips tingle...but not blue! And as I repeated the B12 , either by injections or sublingually, I would go a brighter red each time. ..also very fatigued less after each time too. And a few days after I'd feel up a step (I think).
This reaction gradually lessened over 2 years presumably as my levels of B12 in my body increased...the amount of redness was less each time, tingling less each time, fatigue...which is why I continuedNow my feet/hands etc should have been going blue..and probably increasingly blue each time?..
it does feel close though.I want you to know I do not expect any answers, but, of course, would be delighted if any ideas did pop into your head...
I also wanted to really thank you for all your help in getting me over the past couple of weeks, in your time, knowledge, but most especially in your support. You have a rare "transcendental" ability to really reach out and touch. I really can't find the right words....
Note-I must be the only high school student to ever get a "-3%" in English on my report card, oh ..and that was before I lost the ability to think of the word I wanted to say, and developed brain fog, and lost a fair whack of brain cells..hopefully at least partly recoverable.
(Just so you don't get the wrong impression, I did get 100% for maths on the same report card).Well I'm back to being a happy fan club member.<g>
I'm sure the last couple of weeks is way better than apathy, but..
Thanks, Jan
BTW ..this has been my personal quote on another forum for a no of years
"To know someone here or there with whom you feel there is understanding in spite of distances or thoughts unexpressed -- that can make of this earth a garden."
Goethe
Posted by Larry Hoover on September 21, 2003, at 5:55:12
In reply to Re: Tyrosine (cont) » Larry Hoover, posted by tealady on September 20, 2003, at 16:59:21
> Just wondered if you had heard of any connection between B12 and numbness and tingling"No. And I can't find anything that even gives me a hint.
> After each B12 needle I'd have a "one step backwards, two steps forwards reaction"...I was hoping I was doing the right hing, but the trend line seem to be on the improve. Each injection the "purple" lessened and the color of feet/hands turned brighter red
> Here's part of a post I did on a PN forum
> "My B12 injection last week caused my to be very fatigued and the palms of my hands to go a bright red and my toes and soles of feet - and a headache for about 4 days. It's been 4 months now and I'm still reacting to the hydrocobalamin injections -I'm still hoping this is the b12 fixing something and NOT some allergic type reaction to the hydrocobalamin making something worse."
> Each needle the reaction has lessened.That actually suggests to me that you were seriously B12 deficient, and that your body had ramped up some enzyme concentrations in a desperate attempt to accomodate what little B12 you had available. That's my educated guess. If it was an allergy, you'd get worse over time, not better. You'd have hives. And you'd have a more severe reaction at the injection site.
> Also methylcobalamin sublinguals have similarbut far weaker reactions.
Suggesting you don't have good gut uptake of B12, consistent with the idea that you were previously seriously deficient in B12.
> I haven't taken any large dose B12 for probably 3 months now. I was going to see where my blood levels got to.
Blood B12 is not a great indicator of status, but it is conveniently measured. It's the amount in your various organs and tissues that really determines your B12 status.
> So how's that rate on originality?
>
> Hugs, JanOh, you're quite original, sweetheart. I don't know quite what to make of you. <grin>
Lar
Posted by Larry Hoover on September 21, 2003, at 6:48:23
In reply to Magnesium ascorbate query, posted by tealady on September 20, 2003, at 18:16:22
> Lar,
>
> > I've been backing down on the large doses of vits/minerals. Last Sunday ( a week ago) I knew I had too much zinc(probably) or selenium from the metallic taste in my mouth. (gone now)
> This was the time I had the filling the previous Friday .If you had a filling, how do you know it wasn't the filling responsible for the taste?
>
> I was mixing magnesium carbonate(light) with ascorbic acid..both in powder formI'm not sure what you mean by light and heavy, in this message.....but, powders can be very dense or not, and that has no bearing on the molecular structure. It just has to do with whether or not the molecules pack tightly together (i.e. they nest together well, like spoons in a stack), or if they don't (like your kitchen gadget drawer).
> the adding some water, stirring until clear and fizzing mostly stopped to remove the Co2, and drinking....to get larger doses of magnesium.
You won't have increased the magnesium in any way, but you will have decreased the tendency to burp after taking mag carbonate.
The acid in the stomach shifts the equilibrium from carbonate (H+ + CO3--) --> bicarbonate (H+ + HCO3-) --> carbon dioxide and water (CO2 + H2O). When you add ascorbic acid to water containing magnesium carbonate, you do it in the glass instead. In any case, you do ensure that the magnesium is fully dissolved, but you will always have the same amount of magnesium, and the same amount of ascorbic acid/ascorbate, after the fact.
> Couple of questions
> - I used about a teaspoon of each usually, mixed together. (tapering off over the days)
>
> With equal amounts of each, any idea of what I was swallowing..I know magnesium ascorbate..but some extra ascorbic acid or extra magnesium carbonate..I suspect extra ascrbic acidI'd have to know exact weights to determine that, but you're getting magnesium and vitamin C. Nothing added. Nothing lost.
> -one of the multis I took had magnesium oxide (heavy) in it...besides weight, like the light is a real light fluffy powder..what , if any is the difference between light and heavy. I can't find this out anywhere. Just curious, no real need to know
Magnesium oxide is a poor source of magnesium. MgO is not a salt. It's a covalent compound. You might get as little as a few percent of the magnesium from it. The rest passes in the stool, unreacted.
> Also I was taking this form of VitC around the time of the injection..from a few hours before the dental visit to a few days after in large doses.Vitamin C is good for the gums.
> I was thinking if when they say VitC is a treatment..do they mean pure ascorbic acid or would magnesium ascorbate achieve the same effectAbsolutely the same effect, so long as you take into account the idea that a fraction of the weight of magnesium ascorbate is magnesium, and the remainder is ascorbate. But, in absolute terms, they're the same. When an ascorbate salt enters the stomach, the strong acid HCl that's present will "overpower" the weak acidity of ascorbic acid. All of the ascorbic acid or ascorbate entering the stomach will be in the form of ascorbic acid after mere seconds. The HCL puts the proton back onto ascorbate.
> ..I'm still confused over acidity stuff..
I hope this isn't more than you wanted to know....
In the most common definition, an acid is any molecule that has a tendency to donate or lose a hydrogen ion (H+). Hydrogen is the simplest atom there is. It is no more than a proton with one electron. So, if hydrogen loses it's electron (to become an ion), it is really nothing more than a naked proton. You may come across the concept that a molecule has been protonated. That's the same thing as saying it picked up a hydrogen ion, or that it reacted with an acid.
In order to differentiate between the acid before and after it has lost a proton, chemists use slightly different forms of the name. Ascorbic acid has all its protons. Ascorbate is the same molecule minus a proton. Because it has lost a proton, ascorbate now has a minus charge.
The minerals that your body needs are all ions. An example would be sodium. In its uncharged state, sodium is a metal that is extraordinarily reactive. Drop a piece of sodium metal into water, and there will be an explosion. What remain in the water after the explosion are sodium ions (Na+). If there happened to be ascorbate ions in the water as well, and you dried the solution, you'd be left with the salt, sodium ascorbate (Na+ and ascorbate-).
There are lots of common acids that are found in our food as their -ates. Glutamic acid, an amino acid, may be supplied as the sodium salt, i.e. monosodium glutamate.
You may also come across the -ate concept in an altogether different context. Organic acids can react with alcohols to form esters. One example that you probably have heard about is the fish oil derivative ethyl eicosapentaenoate (E-EPA), used to treat depression. In this example, ethanol (drinking alcohol) has been reacted with the omega-3 fatty acid EPA (eicosapentaenoic acid) to form an ester. The name follows a particular pattern. The alcohol takes on the -yl ending, and the acid takes on the -ate ending. Thus, ethyl eicosapentaenoate. The acid in your stomach breaks the ester apart, giving free ethanol and eicosapentaenoic acid.
Another example of an ester is a triglyceride. Glycerin is an alcohol with three alcohol groups. It can form three ester bonds with individual fatty acids.
> As always I value your help,
> Hugs, JanLet me know if I can expand on any of these ideas for you.
Hugs,
Lar
Posted by tealady on September 21, 2003, at 6:51:21
In reply to Re: B12 reaction » tealady, posted by Larry Hoover on September 21, 2003, at 5:55:12
>Blood B12 is not a great indicator of status, but it is conveniently measured. It's the amount in your various organs and tissues that really determines your B12 status.
> So how's that rate on originality?
>
> Hugs, JanOh, you're quite original, sweetheart. I don't know quite what to make of you. <grin>
Thanks Lar. <grin> that makes two of us!
My blood level B4 I started injections/supps was 347... slightly higher in the US units(range from memory starts about 150 over here), ..lowish, but nothing drastic (most do best over 500, which I 've heard is the minimum in Japan).
I know , blood levels not a good indicator as you say...but I would have expected lower if the main cause of the reactionsJan
Posted by Larry Hoover on September 21, 2003, at 6:51:28
In reply to Re: NADH methemoglobulin reductase » Lar, posted by tealady on September 20, 2003, at 18:54:35
> Just wanted to add this to the post..forgot it!
> This was the enzyme I was looking for in the pathways that I couldn't find.
>
> But I could be barking up the wrong tree.
>
>
> Methemoglobinemia; a description of a case of NADH methemoglobulin reductase deficiency
> http://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/entrez/query.fcgi?cmd=Retrieve&db=PubMed&list_uids=7254639&dopt=Abstract&itool=iconabstr
>
> I'm hoping NADH may be able to bypass it..well a little hope?
> Not even sure this is what is happening..just grasping for an answer
>
>
> JanIn this case, NADH is a cofactor. The only way it would help is if you were deficient in NADH to begin with (always a possibility, in cases of persistent fatigue). If you truly had this enzyme defect, I'd suspect you'd always be cyanotic, rather than only temporarily after B12 injection.
I know one thing. NADH has really helped me.
Lar
Posted by tealady on September 21, 2003, at 7:34:59
In reply to Re: NADH methemoglobulin reductase » tealady, posted by Larry Hoover on September 21, 2003, at 6:51:28
Lar,
I'm not sure, but if you have missed it, could you please look at this post
http://www.dr-bob.org/babble/alter/20030903/msgs/261905.html
I had the wrong title.This is what I am struggling with at present and where I "got" the idea of NADH methemoglobulin reductase from..and what I really would like some help on..or direction on where to go for help, if possible.
It's about my reactions to the dental anesthetic I had on 4th September....
and then the B12 comes in from studies which is why I bought it up..I also found old diary notes where I had milder but similar reactions to early B12 needles (in the first month), regarding headaches, anxiety, panic, tingling etc lasting a week.
Thanks, Jan
Posted by Larry Hoover on September 21, 2003, at 8:13:03
In reply to Thanks Lar..feeling a lot better, posted by tealady on September 21, 2003, at 5:14:39
> Hi Lar,
>
> Me again!
> (I've outworn my welcome even with myself!)Not.
> I also wanted to really thank you for all your help in getting me over the past couple of weeks, in your time, knowledge, but most especially in your support. You have a rare "transcendental" ability to really reach out and touch. I really can't find the right words....
I think you've expressed yourself well....I'm grateful for your kind words.
> Thanks, Jan
>
> BTW ..this has been my personal quote on another forum for a no of years
>
> "To know someone here or there with whom you feel there is understanding in spite of distances or thoughts unexpressed -- that can make of this earth a garden."
> GoetheThanks. You made my day. <sigh>
Lar
Posted by Larry Hoover on September 21, 2003, at 9:28:44
In reply to Re: NADH methemoglobulin reductase » Larry Hoover, posted by tealady on September 21, 2003, at 7:34:59
> Lar,
> I'm not sure, but if you have missed it, could you please look at this post
> http://www.dr-bob.org/babble/alter/20030903/msgs/261905.html
> I had the wrong title.I've been trying to make sense of the delayed reaction, but it really doesn't make sense to me, unless you have substantial neuropathy. The -caine anaesthetics block sodium channels in nerve membranes. With the channel blocked, the neuron can't fire. If it can't fire, you can't feel.
There's some dependency on the speed of induction of anaesthesia based on tissue pH, but if yours was that awry, I'd be thinking about funeral arrangments.
I can't understand why your reaction would be so delayed. Did this happen once, or is it a pattern?
> This is what I am struggling with at present and where I "got" the idea of NADH methemoglobulin reductase from..and what I really would like some help on..or direction on where to go for help, if possible.
There is always some methemoglobin produced during metabolism of prilocaine. It's a matter of degree, with some people having more than others. If you're deficient in NADH, your recovery period would be prolonged, but it would not be more pronounced than it would otherwise be.
With the collection of symptoms you describe (over multiple posts), you do sound like you might benefit from NADH. Enada is the company that patented the process, but they license the product to numerous vendors. I would presume there is an Aussie vendor.
> It's about my reactions to the dental anesthetic I had on 4th September....
> and then the B12 comes in from studies which is why I bought it up..
>
> I also found old diary notes where I had milder but similar reactions to early B12 needles (in the first month), regarding headaches, anxiety, panic, tingling etc lasting a week.
>
> Thanks, JanThose latter symptoms are suggestive of prostaglandin/cytokine reactions. Hyper-reaction of some sort. You may find that a COX-inhibitor reduces that reaction. That's one of the class that includes aspirin, naproxen, ibuprofen, paracetamol, etc. Or, you could just use tumeric. It has a potent COX inhibitor in it. I prefer it to prescription anti-inflammatories, myself. It's more potent, and lasts longer than anything else I've ever used. I just stir a heaping spoonful into a glass of water, and chug it down. Careful, though, it'll stain anything it touches.
Lar
Posted by Kacy on September 21, 2003, at 11:35:13
In reply to Re: amalgam » Kacy, posted by Larry Hoover on September 20, 2003, at 7:20:09
Posted by tealady on September 27, 2003, at 1:46:33
In reply to Re: Magnesium ascorbate query » tealady, posted by Larry Hoover on September 21, 2003, at 6:48:23
> > Lar,
> >
> > > I've been backing down on the large doses of vits/minerals. Last Sunday ( a week ago) I knew I had too much zinc(probably) or selenium from the metallic taste in my mouth. (gone now)
> > This was the time I had the filling the previous Friday .
>
> If you had a filling, how do you know it wasn't the filling responsible for the taste?Caus, it didn't taste like a filling? the one thing good about this fillng is it's tasteless.
Also didn't taste like amalgam.>
> > the adding some water, stirring until clear and fizzing mostly stopped to remove the Co2, and drinking....to get larger doses of magnesium.
>
> You won't have increased the magnesium in any way, but you will have decreased the tendency to burp after taking mag carbonate.Sigh, I sure wrote that wrong. I meant to get larger doses of magnesium..without resorting to taking epsoms salts in larger quantities, or many pills etc.
>
> The acid in the stomach shifts the equilibrium from carbonate (H+ + CO3--) --> bicarbonate (H+ + HCO3-) --> carbon dioxide and water (CO2 + H2O). When you add ascorbic acid to water containing magnesium carbonate, you do it in the glass instead. In any case, you do ensure that the magnesium is fully dissolved, but you will always have the same amount of magnesium, and the same amount of ascorbic acid/ascorbate, after the fact.yep, figured that much
>
> > Couple of questions
> > - I used about a teaspoon of each usually, mixed together. (tapering off over the days)
> >
> > With equal amounts of each, any idea of what I was swallowing..I know magnesium ascorbate..but some extra ascorbic acid or extra magnesium carbonate..I suspect extra ascorbic acid
>
> I'd have to know exact weights to determine that, but you're getting magnesium and vitamin C. Nothing added. Nothing lost.aaah..that is what counts is it. This magnesium carbonate is real light..like a 250ml container is almost weightless..you think its empty till you open it. So probably not a lot of magnesium in a teaspoon then, right?
I got this for $8 , I can't source any more for under $56 (although a few places left to try)..and probably not even that as factory closed for upgrade under govt pressure for about 6 weeks
> > -one of the multis I took had magnesium oxide (heavy) in it...besides weight, like the light is a real light fluffy powder..what , if any is the difference between light and heavy. I can't find this out anywhere. Just curious, no real need to know
>
> Magnesium oxide is a poor source of magnesium. MgO is not a salt. It's a covalent compound. You might get as little as a few percent of the magnesium from it. The rest passes in the stool, unreacted.
>
> > Also I was taking this form of VitC around the time of the injection..from a few hours before the dental visit to a few days after in large doses.
>
> Vitamin C is good for the gums.Yes, I know. I need to take it in larger doses for at least a week before I see a dentist or they won't treat me, as my gums get too red and swollen, and bleed too easy.
If I take VitC all the time, the effect wears off..so I prefer to keep the larger doses for certain times, like dentistry, stress etc.>
> > I was thinking if when they say VitC is a treatment..do they mean pure ascorbic acid or would magnesium ascorbate achieve the same effect
>
> Absolutely the same effect, so long as you take into account the idea that a fraction of the weight of magnesium ascorbate is magnesium, and the remainder is ascorbate. But, in absolute terms, they're the same. When an ascorbate salt enters the stomach, the strong acid HCl that's present will "overpower" the weak acidity of ascorbic acid. All of the ascorbic acid or ascorbate entering the stomach will be in the form of ascorbic acid after mere seconds. The HCL puts the proton back onto ascorbate.Lar, thanks heaps. That means I was doing the right thing even if I was getting some methaemoglobulin reaction thingy. I'm still convinced it has something to do with it.
I have a slight nitrate reaction too..I'll find out what enzyme that is again, and get back to you on it, if I may? I'm think it's tied in too. I have to go now.>
> > ..I'm still confused over acidity stuff..
>
> I hope this isn't more than you wanted to know....
>
ta , I've printed it out and read it a few times.
One day I am going to get a brain again.
My doc mentioned selegiline...when I told her I was adding in T4 to try to help my brain...on the basis that T4 may possibly be transported over blood-brain barrier easier, and my Ft4 levels were near bottom of range.She said some guy who had held a fairly high job, I've forgotten what, was involved in a crash....and his brain power/ concentration/ short term memory seemed to go.. and all he seemed to be able to do was driving, he was coping with that fine...He started on selegiline and got his brain back...and returned to his old job.
I've been prescribed DHEA & 7keto DHEA to try ..she reckoned it might help my brain and reckoned the DHEA helped her lose weight?.
Other docs say its only for men usually.... I guess I'll get it filled next week and give it a try.
Hope I don't grow a mou. or more zits.(that's why I got the 7-keto one as well, as its not supposed to convert to anything)Oh Lar, about those pathways..I think a small percentage can back up the reverse way , different amount at different enzymes?
Do you think it's possible that some of that tyrosine(when I tried it) was converting back to PEA that way at all?thanks,
Jan> > Hugs, Jan
>
> Let me know if I can expand on any of these ideas for you.
>
> Hugs,
> Lar
Go forward in thread:
Psycho-Babble Alternative | Extras | FAQ
Dr. Bob is Robert Hsiung, MD,
bob@dr-bob.org
Script revised: February 4, 2008
URL: http://www.dr-bob.org/cgi-bin/pb/mget.pl
Copyright 2006-17 Robert Hsiung.
Owned and operated by Dr. Bob LLC and not the University of Chicago.