Re: real relationships vs. transference....

Posted by Solstice on December 19, 2010, at 11:52:50

In reply to Re: real relationships vs. transference...., posted by violette on December 19, 2010, at 11:46:08

Violette - I think I was referring to his education, training, and work giving him a saturated exposure to anything and everything 'psych'. Some ideas, of course, will be more salient for him than others. Point is, that his tendency to say things that are transferential is more likely due to that overexposure rather than him trying to create a dr./pt dynamic, etc.
Solstice

> > but.. maybe it's also a reflection of his training and work becoming embedded in his thinking. I know that my traning and work is embedded in how I relate to people.
>
> Solstice, I'm totally lost on this one. I thought Dr. Bob was a psychatrist-I did not know he was a psychoanalyst too-is he/are you Bob? My experience with most psychiatrists is that they didn't focus on psychology, but have an education in biochemistry, how the brain and body works etc. and understand symptoms in terms of cognitive function as opposed to object relations. My psychiatrist went to school for at least 4 more years for his psychoanalytic studies after he completed his psychiatry education and residency/MD. I always viewed Dr. Bob as a behavioralist, at least from what I have seen on this forum, rather than someone who understands transference and object relations.
>
> > Maybe it makes some of you feel the way you did when you were a child.
>
> http://www.dr-bob.org/babble/admin/20101014/msgs/971715.html
>
> I dont' recall a psychoanalyst ever stating something so simplistic as this during the course of psychoanalytic therapy. But - this is interesting to me becaues my perspective of Dr. Bob is totally different (at least in some respects) than the perspectives of both you and Twinleaf. Of course we are all different, so that would be expected...still interesting. I think Bob is more behavioral oriented, and his semi-frequent posts about our childhood seem totally out of context to me in terms of Bob's stated ideals and other philosphies he displays here.

Thread

Amnesty - Dr.Bob and all hyperfocus 10/3/10
...
Re: real relationships vs. transference.... solstice 12/13/10
Re: real relationships vs. transference.... muffled 12/13/10
Re: some kind of Elders Council Dinah 12/14/10
Re: some kind of Elders Council Willful 12/14/10
some kind of Elders Council - some Willful Wisdom Solstice 12/14/10
Re: some kind of Elders Council Dinah 12/14/10
Re: some kind of Elders Council Solstice 12/14/10
Re: opportunity to support twinleaf Dr. Bob 12/19/10
Re: some kind of Community Council Dr. Bob 12/19/10
Re: opportunity to support twinleaf twinleaf 12/19/10
Re: real relationships vs. transference.... violette 12/19/10
Re: some kind of Community Council Solstice 12/19/10
Re: real relationships vs. transference.... Solstice 12/19/10
Re: some kind of Community Council muffled 12/19/10
Re: thanks (nm) » twinleaf Dr. Bob 12/19/10
Re: some kind of Community Council Dr. Bob 12/21/10
Re: some kind of Community Council » Dr. Bob muffled 12/21/10
Re: some kind of Community Council twinleaf 12/21/10
Re: some kind of Community Council Dr. Bob 12/22/10
Re: some kind of Community Council » Dr. Bob muffled 12/25/10
Re: some kind of Community Council » Dr. Bob sigismund 12/26/10
Re: some kind of Community Council Dr. Bob 12/27/10
Re: some kind of Community Council » Dr. Bob sigismund 12/27/10
Re: some kind of Community Council » Dr. Bob Dinah 12/27/10
Re: some kind of Community Council Dinah 12/27/10
...
Re: percents sigismund 12/31/10

Post a new follow-up

Notify the administrators

Start a new thread

poster:Solstice thread:964630
URL: http://www.dr-bob.org/babble/admin/20101201/msgs/973988.html