Posted by alexandra_k on October 15, 2006, at 21:43:11
In reply to Lou's response to aspects of gardenergirl's post-, posted by Lou Pilder on October 15, 2006, at 21:18:18
you want to know whether something you want to post is likely to be considered civil or not.
> it says that anyone can always ask him if the post is OK.
sure, anyone can ask him, but if you are wanting a timely response...
> if he means that I really do not have to ask others and I have not seen a reply to me from him as to if he mans that.would it have helped if he has said 'pretty please with sugar on top'?
> Also, Dr. Hsiung says that he knows it when he sees it. Others can see it to.
yes. hence you might get a more timely response that is in line with bob's response if you were to ask someone else.
> what is ther to be seen her?
i thought you wanted to know whether your proposed post is likely to be considered civil.
> I am asking him to review a link from the Anti-Defamation league as a response to statements that IMO have the potential to accuse Jews and the potential IMO to foster defamtion toward Jews and me as a Jew on the forum
that doesn't involve your accusing other people of making statements, or your making statements yourself that have the potential to accuse Jews and the potential to foster defamation etc etc - does it? i would say that not only are OTHER people not allowed to do this, but YOU are not allowed to do this either.
> One is if the statements in question do have the potential to arrouse antisemitic feeling if left unsanctioned
so you don't think they would have the potential to arouse antisemitic feeling if they were sanctioned?
> and the other question is if the post that I want to send him is civil.
right. and he requested (pretty please with sugar on top) how about you ask someone else FIRST and see what they have to say.
> I think that it is an additional standard to me, if I have to ask others before I send it to him
he didn't say you HAVE to ask others, he REQUESTED you to ask others:
how about you do x
don't do ycan you hear the difference?
> I know that I can ask others , but {must} I ask others before I send my request to Dr. Hsiung?
you don't have to Lou,
but then Bob doesn't have to respond to your every request either...
poster:alexandra_k
thread:688245
URL: http://www.dr-bob.org/babble/admin/20060918/msgs/695148.html