Posted by Lou Pilder on October 15, 2006, at 21:18:18
In reply to Asking others to preview posts, posted by gardenergirl on October 15, 2006, at 20:55:10
Friends,
It is written here,[...you can ask (someone)...to preview your posts...].
Well, if this is in response to the overiding issue here in this thread then I have the following response.
People can ask anyone that will hear them what they think of a post. But does that option resolve what is the issue here in this thread?
Theissue here in this thread is my request to Dr. Hsiung to review a post of mine before it is posted to find out if it is OK. His reply to me is to ask other first and then email it to him. The FAQno restriction for asking him, for it says that anyone can always ask him if the post is OK.
Now there are several issues about Dr. Hsiung replying to me with that statement to ask others.
In my reply to him, one of the aspects to the discussion I listed as toif he means that I really do not have to ask others and I have not seen a reply to me from him as to if he mans that.
Also, Dr. Hsiung says that he knows it when he sees it. Others can see it to. zbut what is ther to be seen her? I am asking him to review a link from the Anti-Defamation league as a response to statements that IMO have the potential to accuse Jews and the potential IMO to foster defamtion toward Jews and me as a Jew on the forum if the statement are not sanctioned like other statements of the same nature concerning non-Jews. So there could be two questions, IMO. One is if the statements in question do have the potential to arrouse antisemitic feeling if left unsanctioned, and the other question is if the post that I want to send him is civil.
I think that it is an additional standard to me, if I have to ask others before I send it to him, if the FAQ does not have that same requirement to others, and thearfore I consider it to be discriminatory if I have to ask others before sending it to him, as having two standards here.
If DR. Hsiung wants other's opinions, he could he not ask others after I send it to him?
I know that I can ask others , but {must} I ask others before I send my request to Dr. Hsiung?
Lou
poster:Lou Pilder
thread:688245
URL: http://www.dr-bob.org/babble/admin/20060918/msgs/695138.html