Posted by Lou Pilder on November 19, 2006, at 10:06:24
In reply to Re: Lou's reply to Li's reply to Lou(2) » Lou Pilder, posted by Lindenblüte on November 19, 2006, at 8:21:23
> > >
> > > > You wrote,[..."yeah,that makes a lot of sense" rather than "Hallelujah,I've been saved"....].
> > > > The grammatical structure of your statement could be of a nature that could not be clear to me and there could be an obscuring of your intended meaning to me because of the use of quotations.
> > > > In your statement in question, it is unclear to me as to if you are using the quotation marks to denote speech, such as calling attention to ironic words, or as a quotation.
> > >
> > > Hi Lou,
> > > The quotation marks are a device that I used in order to reflect the fact that I often have a voice in my head. This voice of the homunculus speaks. Says things like "Aha!" "stupid Lindenblüte" etc.
> > >
> > > -Li
> >
> > Li,
> > You wrote,[...the voice of the homunculus speaks...]
> > Could you clarify if then which of the quotes are from the homunculus or not and if the quote, [..."Hallelujah, I've been saved"...]is from the homunculus, and the other is not, or if the quote,[..."yeah,that makes a lot of sense"...]is from the homunculus and the other is not, or both are from the homunculus or niether are form the homunculus? If you could, then I could have a better understanding of what you have posted and be able to better offer you support from my perspective.
> > Lou
> >
>
> Both are from the homunculus. I'm interested in seeing where you're going with this...Li,
You wrote,[...Both are from the homunculus.I'm interested in seeing where you're going with this...].
I think that I could give a better reply to you if you could clarify the statement of yours,[... voice of the homunculus speaks..."Aha!" "(csnsored by respondant) Lindenblute" etc...] as pertaining to are you saying any of the following?
A. What ,in your opinion, was the reason that the homunculus spoke to you saying something like, [...(csnsored by respondant) Lindenblute...}?
B. Do you accept the speaking to you from the homunculus as to be fact?
C. Do you have a background of the writings of Gibert Ryle?
D.(deleted by respondant) you could email me if you like for this
E. In the quote of yours,[..."yeah, that makes a lot of sense" rather than "Hallelujah, I've been saved."...],if you are quoting the homunclulus, does this mean to you that the homunculus is saying that the concept of salvation that other faiths embrace does not make sense?
Lou
poster:Lou Pilder
thread:703557
URL: http://www.dr-bob.org/babble/faith/20060614/msgs/705210.html