Posted by Estella on August 20, 2006, at 1:43:45
In reply to Re: Lou's response to discriminative membership, posted by Lou Pilder on August 19, 2006, at 23:05:06
>I now have come to the realization that I will never have those statements that put down Jews to be sanctioned.
Dr Bob doesn't seem to interpret those statements as being statements that put down Jews. My guess would be that if he saw those statements as putting down Jews then he would indeed sanction them. He just doesn't see them as being statements that put down Jews.
You have posted other people the links.
Did they interpret them as statements that put down Jews? Sounds like there is (at least) one other and probably a lot more than one other Jew here. Did the others interpret those statements as being statements that put down Jews?
> Be it known here that I have been trying for years to have these type of statements sanctioned,so I do not think that they will ever be.
I think the dispute is over whether the instances you have cited are indeed instances of a type of statements that put down Jews. You think they are, others don't interpret them in that way.
> I have to accept what puts me down
I'm sorry that you felt those statements put you down.
> I will be expelled for showing that statements and quotes that have the potential to arrouse antisemitic feelings are considered to be civil here.
I'm not sure that that is it. I think it might be more about your insisting that those statements put down Jews when other people (including other Jews) don't interpret those statements in that way.
> I just happen to have thought that it was sponsored by the university of Chicago and would follow the guidlines of the university.
The cite isn't sponsored by U Chicago. There was a time that the cite did count as research but it hasn't counted as research for quite a while now. I think that Dr Bob AND the University wouldn't think that statements that put down Jews were acceptable. I also think, however, that the University would likely agree with Bob's determination that those statements aren't attempts to put down Jews.
If you felt put down by them you could have posted something to the poster like 'I interpreted your post in such a way that I thought you might have been trying to put me down for my faith'. Usually... People are fairly willing to say 'Oh, that wasn't what I intended I'm sorry if you felt upset'. I'm sorry things have gone badly for you there... I hope you stick around.
poster:Estella
thread:678122
URL: http://www.dr-bob.org/babble/admin/20060802/msgs/678363.html