Posted by alexandra_k on December 28, 2005, at 19:24:00
In reply to Re: Hey » alexandra_k, posted by gardenergirl on December 28, 2005, at 18:58:47
> I've planned and given professional presentations in my field for a few years. Granted, I've never asked clients or "patients" to present with me, but as the chair of the program, I've not had to obtain informed consent of any kind to invite speakers to present with me.
i didn't get the impression that babblers were being asked to 'present with' dr bob. i thought kali munroe and dr-bob were going to do a joint presentation and babblers...
were there to answer questions that the atendees may have for them...
> A presentation at a professional conference presents data versus collects data. One does not need to give informed consent to present "data"
though...
in order to present data you usually need to collect it first.
so, for instance, when dr-bob gave a seminar a while back he asked people to post (offer data) about their experiences and there people were required to give informed consent before hand. i don't see how that is different to this round... why did they have to give informed consent to offer their experiences for a seminar last time but not this time?> in this case, personal experiences of posting on Babble.
assuming... the people at the conference ASK about their experiences. do we really know what sorts of questions they are likely to ask? i guess dr-bob would have more of an idea because they probably ask him similar types of questions... i would have thought... psychiatrists may be more inclined to try and figure the quality of the medication information... might be more interested in that than peoples 'personal experiences' of support etc but then i suppose i could be wrong... i guess dr bob would know what people are likely to ask...
poster:alexandra_k
thread:584230
URL: http://www.dr-bob.org/babble/admin/20051205/msgs/592865.html