Posted by shar on July 21, 2002, at 6:38:05
In reply to He shouldn't get away with this, posted by mair on July 20, 2002, at 12:44:21
> I support kiddo. She's right, Lou never said a word about her post being accusatory until Bob cautioned her. More importantly, there was nothing inherently accusatory in kiddo's post...
Mair, I agree with what you've written. However, I've gotten confused because
(1) The PBC by Dr. Bob to Kiddo said "but I don't think it's supportive here to imply that there's only one "right" road..."
Then,
(2) Lou responded "My concern is that your posts, to me, go over the line and constitute anti-Semitic rhetoric. I base that on the same post that Dr. Bob flagged *and* your other post about your accusation that the pharisees were hypocrites...etc." [emphasis mine]
(3) Unless I am mistaken, Dr. Bob only said (in essence) 'don't say that your way is the one right way.' He never said anything at all about other posts, or what they implied, or how they might be understood or misunderstood, or that there was something inherently anti-Semitic in any post.
So,
(4) I believe Lou has attributed to Dr. Bob some agreement with Lou's stance (for example, Lou's statement "to be some kind of implied condemnation to the pharisees, to me, for , and Dr. Bob agrees") when I don't find that anywhere. Dr. Bob's statement was quite clear and clearly limited to the no-one-right-way idea, I thought.I have reread the posts, and imo the original PBC got turned into something it is not, and that most of the discussion does not center around the point of the PBC.
I also think this is either a lose-lose situation, or people will just have to agree to disagree about an interpretation of the bible parts, and, I hope, come to a gracious end.
Shar
poster:shar
thread:6370
URL: http://www.dr-bob.org/babble/admin/20020627/msgs/6449.html