![[dr. bob]](/dr-bob-sm.gif)
Dr. Bob is Robert Hsiung, MD,
bob@dr-bob.orgShown: posts 16 to 40 of 76. Go back in thread:
Posted by Dinah on July 19, 2004, at 13:48:18
In reply to you know what?, posted by karen_kay on July 19, 2004, at 13:25:56
Besides, Fires posted more than once after stating his intention to leave. Actually he has stated his intention to leave several times, and still posted. What makes you think anyone was driven off? This time I mean.
I don't really understand the motivations of a rabidly anti-therapist poster posting on a board devoted to therapy. The only possible point would be to try to convert people to an anti-therapy viewpoint. Unless I'm missing another possible intended result? Which I well may be. Do you think anti-therapist posters are really trying to understand why therapy is helpful and that's why they post on a therapy board? I suppose that's possible... And trying to convert people to an anti-therapy position on a board devoted to therapy is a quixotic proposition at best. Anyone certainly has the right to do it, but I don't see many opportunities for pleasant outcomes to be enjoyed.
But perhaps I'm missing a pleasant outcome?
Now Social is different. A rabidly anti-therapy poster could converse quite sociably on any number of topics. Just as I, a conservative, manage to usually feel at home on this largely liberal board.
Posted by partlycloudy on July 19, 2004, at 13:48:31
In reply to you know what?, posted by karen_kay on July 19, 2004, at 13:25:56
Sorry, but I think the board as a whole already has given second and more chances. Invitations for posters to share their stories (which get the invitee rebuffed or worse, insulted). It really makes for an atmosphere that is completely unsupportive. I too was bullied enough in school to last for the rest of my life. I've been the outsider my entire life. I thought I could be safe here, accepted, supported. There are already posters whose threads I stay away from *which was Dr. Bob's advice* when I was upset the last time.
Also what is going on with someone who posts, gets everybody all riled up, and then backs away, only to return to repeat the action when it's quietened down? Am I paranoid or what???????
Posted by TexasChic on July 19, 2004, at 13:50:48
In reply to Re: May I disagree with my friends? » TexasChic, posted by Dinah on July 19, 2004, at 13:17:41
I don't think either one of us was offended. She went on to answer his question about the conflicts he thought he saw in her posts.
I don't understand why everyone thinks he left. I don't see a post of that.
I do understand why pc was upset about the previous confrontation though. Maybe there should be something in the guidelines about questioning the validity of someone's treatment? That's a kind of put down isn't it?
I hope I didn't break any rules saying that.
Posted by Dinah on July 19, 2004, at 13:51:34
In reply to Re: you know what? » karen_kay, posted by Dinah on July 19, 2004, at 13:48:18
I meant to say that I feel largely at home on Social, despite my conservative orientation. But I'd avoid Psycho-Babble Politics at all costs. Because no one would be likely to convert to conservatism because of my brilliant arguments, and it would just lead to bad feelings.
Posted by AuntieMel on July 19, 2004, at 15:28:02
In reply to Re: May I disagree with my friends? » TofuEmmy, posted by Dinah on July 19, 2004, at 12:48:22
Well, my buttons weren't pressed on any of these discussions, so I've been looking at it from a distance. I'll try to give my perspective as an outsider.
S(H)e seems to be a bit of a wounded animal, too. The kind that will bite your arm off if you try to get too close. Some need comforting, some are very self proctive. Different ways of reacting to the same feelings.
I started looking at this pretty late, but my first "view" of a therapy thread began with fires' questions about cognitive therapy. (June 5) These questions seemed to be perfecly reasonable, although there was a request that the info about CBT not come from a psychonalist. It seemed to me that he had a really bad experience in therapy.
The biggest mistake I saw in this discourse was that it didn't stay on topic. One person had had a bad experience with analysis and didn't want to discuss it, others felt from that that their own therapy was being attacked. The truth was probably somewhere in the middle. But, when you are emotionally invested in what you are trying to do for yourself it is hard to see another side.
After that it seems that everyone was expecting the worse - and finding it.
I never got the impression fires was anti-therapy, just that he had bad experiences with it. Maybe hi is looking for someone with good experiences? Something to base hope on?
Posted by Dinah on July 19, 2004, at 16:06:02
In reply to Re: May I disagree with my friends? » Dinah, posted by AuntieMel on July 19, 2004, at 15:28:02
I suppose the following posts (among others) led me to think he was anti-therapy - except perhaps for brief CBT therapy. I didn't get the feeling he was asking for reassurances that therapy might help, since he specifically told posters that he doubted that any gains they made were from therapy. But I could be mistaken and maybe he has a deep seated desire for interpersonal connection and a meaningful therapeutic relationship and is merely disappointed that he hasn't been able to achieve what so many other people get so much benefit from. I certainly wouldn't want to leap to any conclusions.
http://www.dr-bob.org/babble/psycho/20040614/msgs/358820.html
http://www.dr-bob.org/babble/psycho/20040614/msgs/358208.html
http://www.dr-bob.org/babble/psycho/20040603/msgs/354355.html
http://www.dr-bob.org/babble/psycho/20040614/msgs/358814.html
particularly "Because relatively short term therapies are the only ones demonstrated to help Dep. Psychoanalysis has never been shown to help any condition, with the exception of the therapists bank account."And as I said, I'd tend to agree about his pain. And I'm sorry for it. My wish for him would be that he be able to achieve the sort of healing therapeutic relationship that so many of us have found so helpful. And maybe a process group....
Posted by Dinah on July 19, 2004, at 16:22:07
In reply to Possible trigger » AuntieMel, posted by Dinah on July 19, 2004, at 16:06:02
My beef was always with Dr. Bob, far more than Fires. It hurt me that he considered some of the things he said civil. I care too much about Dr. Bob, and only those I care about can hurt me.
So the answer is simple! Quit caring about Dr. Bob, and quit posting about areas I'm vulnerable in. Sort of a shame, since I haven't felt free to comment on many threads when I feel like I could contribute on the topic because I've let Dr. Bob's and Fires cause shame to overwhelm me. But that's the way it goes, and maybe it's better that way anyway. Not feeling safe reduces attachment, and lack of attachment is safe. :)
So maybe I should thank Fires and Dr. Bob instead of being angry?
Posted by TexasChic on July 19, 2004, at 16:33:00
In reply to Ahhhh, it's not worth it., posted by Dinah on July 19, 2004, at 16:22:07
How did Dr. Bob and Fire cause you shame!!?? Without going back through the archives, I feel you've always been very considerate and caring.
I hate that everyone is so upset. I wish I knew what to say to make it better.
:-(
Posted by AuntieMel on July 19, 2004, at 16:41:57
In reply to Ahhhh, it's not worth it., posted by Dinah on July 19, 2004, at 16:22:07
Dinah - did I say anything to trigger you? If so, I certainly didn't mean to.
So, in the spirit of getting along (smiling, really) I'll discontinue with my opinions on this topic. I'm clearly in the minority (still smiling)
Posted by Dinah on July 19, 2004, at 17:30:55
In reply to Re: Ahhhh, it's not worth it. » Dinah, posted by AuntieMel on July 19, 2004, at 16:41:57
Nothing triggered. I'm fine. I just feel like it's not something I want to expend energy on. I've already wasted too much energy on it as it is. I understand why I was upset. I think I'll continue trying to protect others from being similarly upset. But that's it. I don't think Fires will be able to hurt me anymore at all. I imagine Dr. Bob still will. :)
No need to apologize. I am just bowing out, that's all.
Posted by Dinah on July 19, 2004, at 17:41:11
In reply to Re: Ahhhh, it's not worth it. » Dinah, posted by TexasChic on July 19, 2004, at 16:33:00
Fires is categorically disbelieving of an aspect of my being. And had distressing website addresses to prove his point. It's a sore spot with me because I know how controversial it is. And Dr. Bob didn't think it was uncivil to assert what he asserted. So Fires upset me, and Bob hurt me. That's all.
It's not really worth being upset over, but it is worth being cautious about.
I really appreciate your concern. It's very kind of you, and the sort of thing I love best about Babble. :)
I hope Partlycloudy is still able to find that here, despite other factors.
Posted by AuntieMel on July 19, 2004, at 17:49:13
In reply to Possible trigger » AuntieMel, posted by Dinah on July 19, 2004, at 16:06:02
OK, I will answer after all. Just can't stop myself, I guess.
I was perhaps trying too hard before to keep in civility guidelines, and ended up being vague instead. And PLEASE, PLEASE don't think for a second that I'm taking sides. I'm way too new here to do that, not knowing all the history and all, and wouldn't do it even if I did.
I'm just cursed with seeing both sides of any issue. Believe me, my life would be a whole lot simpler if I could have an opinion and stick to it.
And I wouldn't dream of trying to judge ANYONE here. I just don't have enough information about what is going on in their life currently or where they are in trying to get better.
Yes, I agree that some of the links you gave were over the top. But, I just can't take them out of context.
> http://www.dr-bob.org/babble/psycho/20040614/msgs/358820.html
At the beginning of the thread (started by someone that was wondering if therapy was making her worse) he seemed to me at least that he was trying to be supportive, share his experience and asked her to try to consider medication if she is feeling suicidal. That seems reasonable to me. But it was immediately followed by a "do not post to me" and the whole thing went downhill from there.
http://www.dr-bob.org/babble/psycho/20040614/msgs/358403.html==============================================
>
>http://www.dr-bob.org/babble/psycho/20040614/msgs/358208.html
>
Well, I for sure had problems with all the links provided here were from skeptic.com. I would have liked to see something from a trade journal.However, he also mentions that he has been criticized elsewhere for disagreeing. Which has made me (until now) way overly careful NOT to disagree. This, in my opinion, isn't helpful - to me at least. I would love for someone to disagree with me and (logically) show me other things to consider. If I had all the answers I wouldn't be here.
Then later he thanked someone for posting something that wasn't anti-therapy, but did talk about reasonable precautions.Thank you for having the courage to say what you did:
"Not all Ts are good and not all good Ts are right for every person. It can be difficult to find a T that is both good and right for you. It seems that you never find one what was. Research shows that depression is best treated by a combination of medication and talk therapy. I think of it like diabetes, insulin compensates for that biological problem ..."Wonderful
=================================================
> http://www.dr-bob.org/babble/psycho/20040603/msgs/354355.html
>
Highly sarcastic, in my opinion. Uncalled for.=================================================
> http://www.dr-bob.org/babble/psycho/20040614/msgs/358814.html
> particularly "Because relatively short term therapies are the only ones demonstrated to help Dep. Psychoanalysis has never been shown to help any condition, with the exception of the therapists bank account."Agreed. But isn't it possible that by then anything would have become a p**sing match?
To be honest (hopefully not brutally) I think from what I've read that if blame MUST be assigned that there is plenty to go around. And two (or 20) wrongs still don't make a right.
But all of that happened, and can't be changed now.
Posted by AuntieMel on July 19, 2004, at 17:56:56
In reply to Re: Ahhhh, it's not worth it. » AuntieMel, posted by Dinah on July 19, 2004, at 17:30:55
Cross posting again (grin)
I agree with you on that one! I think everyone has used much, much, much more energy than needed.
And, again, please don't feel offended by anything I say. I feel like the little kid wanting everyone to just get along! And my natural tendancy to try to mediate, even when I know I shouldn't.
I'm not sure what aspect of your being is being questioned. I must have missed something. Was it when he said something about DID? I have to admit that one went totally over my head.
Peace??
Posted by partlycloudy on July 19, 2004, at 18:09:08
In reply to Solidarity, posted by partlycloudy on July 19, 2004, at 9:15:18
I stand by my original post. I'm not going anywhere (away from Babble, that is)!
Posted by gardenergirl on July 19, 2004, at 18:15:05
In reply to Re: Ahhhh, it's not worth it. » Dinah, posted by AuntieMel on July 19, 2004, at 17:56:56
>
> I agree with you on that one! I think everyone has used much, much, much more energy than needed.
>I know that I have invested too much energy in this. I can't help but wonder how this thread may come across to others, and what effect on others' psyches it may have. But that's the T in training in me talking. :)
gg
Posted by gardenergirl on July 19, 2004, at 18:31:50
In reply to Re: Solidarity » partlycloudy, posted by partlycloudy on July 19, 2004, at 18:09:08
PC,
I'm so glad you aren't going away. That would surely be a loss. I hope that as things calm down here again, it will again feel safe. And I also hope that safe doesn't perhaps bore people enough to want to generate some "excitement".Take care,
gg
Posted by Dinah on July 19, 2004, at 18:39:54
In reply to Re: Ahhhh, it's not worth it., posted by gardenergirl on July 19, 2004, at 18:15:05
Yeah, I worry too. And I worry that my trying to make things better just makes them worse. And I worry all sorts of things. I certainly don't want to add to the negative ambience here.
I'm just so tired.
And sad. i'm sad.
Posted by pegasus on July 19, 2004, at 18:45:24
In reply to Re: Ahhhh, it's not worth it. » gardenergirl, posted by Dinah on July 19, 2004, at 18:39:54
I think babble is bigger than this little tiff. I mean, in a few weeks, we'll have moved on to other issues. Babble is like a community IRL where people come, people go, people get in conflict, people resolve conflict, people carry lifelong grudges, and they forgive each other, but the overall community is always there in the end.
At least, that's how I'm choosing to view this latest episode. I'm planning to still be here when the dust settles, to carry on as usual. I really hope all of you all will be there, too, but I support everyone to do what they think is best for them.
pegasus
Posted by Elle2021 on July 20, 2004, at 7:14:11
In reply to you know what?, posted by karen_kay on July 19, 2004, at 13:25:56
> i just try to keep in mind through this whole thing that this is a site for mental health, and that all of us have mental health issues, or we wouldn't be here.
I think that is such an excellent point, and one I always try to keep in mind when I read and write posts on here.
> is it really fair to try and run someone off.No.
>can't we forgive and just forget? try to jsut start over again? is that a viable option rather than throwing stones and turning someone away?
I have confidence that the Babblers here are capable of forgiveness. I wasn't involved in any of the conversations that are being spoke of here, but I did read them. Seems like both sides said some not-very-nice things. But, aren't we all guilty of saying at least one or two not-so-nice things in the past?
>i think we've done it for others, haven't we?
Yes, we have.
> go ahead, let me have it.. maybe this post will be what i'm talking about? as in talking too much and hoping for forgiveness? maybe not, but i'm still saying it since no one else is.....
Your a brave woman.
> ok, wincing as i hit submit :)Me too...
Posted by Elle2021 on July 20, 2004, at 7:18:27
In reply to Re: you know what? » karen_kay, posted by Dinah on July 19, 2004, at 13:48:18
> I don't really understand the motivations of a rabidly anti-therapist poster posting on a board devoted to therapy. The only possible point would be to try to convert people to an anti-therapy viewpoint. Unless I'm missing another possible intended result?
Kinda seemed to me as if he/she was trying to talk himself out of that idea of being anti-therapist. But, that's just my take on it.
Elle
Posted by Dinah on July 20, 2004, at 8:04:36
In reply to Re: you know what? » Dinah, posted by Elle2021 on July 20, 2004, at 7:18:27
As I said, not my take on it. But you're as free to form your own conclusions as I am.
And I really have wasted enough energy on this. I will *not* post again on the subject of fires.
H*ll, y'all are free to start a "Please Come Back Fires" thread on PPB. It's no concern of mine. Everyone is welcome here as long as they follow Dr. Bob's civility guidelines, and Dr. Bob thinks fires' posts are fine. Therefore by definition, they're perfectly appropriate Babble posts.
Posted by Dinah on July 20, 2004, at 8:12:44
In reply to Re: you know what? » Elle2021, posted by Dinah on July 20, 2004, at 8:04:36
I would never want to be rude to anyone, and if I was part of "driving him off" I'd like to make amends. I'm sure you guys will give him a warm welcome and help him feel right at home. Perhaps you could protect some of the other posters at the same time, and do a double good deed.
Posted by Dinah on July 20, 2004, at 9:01:00
In reply to Re: I asked Fires to return., posted by Dinah on July 20, 2004, at 8:12:44
I'm sure those who were telling us that the PPB posters were treating Fires unkindly will want to be an example to the rest of us. Whenever I tell my husband he's loading the dishwasher wrong, I make sure I'm willing to load the dishwasher myself.
Posted by AuntieMel on July 20, 2004, at 10:54:06
In reply to Re: I asked Fires to return., posted by Dinah on July 20, 2004, at 8:12:44
And I do mean that. I think I was trying extra hard to to explain my feelings to you because your opinion means a lot to me.
Posted by DaisyM on July 20, 2004, at 11:38:38
In reply to Re: Very, Very Gracious of you - please read » Dinah, posted by AuntieMel on July 20, 2004, at 10:54:06
I've had my head under the pillow...
I've said before that since I have to be the "big boss/grownup" IRL I refuse to expend enormous amounts of energy being a diplomat here. I can't/don't want to fight the fight for the greater good. I'm impressed by all of you who do that for me. I want to get support (yesterday was a prime example of how critical Babble can be for some of us and was "Babble at its best!") and give support. I also like to have fun on occasion. The thread about the road trip had me smiling for days.
My solution is to avoid certain posters or not get involved in threads where I can't help. I like to debate as much as the next person (Rod and I have gone round about brain development) but sometimes it is just too personal. *sigh*
I'm sorry if this is a cop-out. But I miss some of the posters who left. And I'm tired of people leaving me...
Go forward in thread:
Psycho-Babble Social | Extras | FAQ
Dr. Bob is Robert Hsiung, MD,
bob@dr-bob.org
Script revised: February 4, 2008
URL: http://www.dr-bob.org/cgi-bin/pb/mget.pl
Copyright 2006-17 Robert Hsiung.
Owned and operated by Dr. Bob LLC and not the University of Chicago.