![[dr. bob]](/dr-bob-sm.gif)
Dr. Bob is Robert Hsiung, MD,
bob@dr-bob.orgShown: posts 14 to 38 of 262. Go back in thread:
Posted by Neal on October 20, 2001, at 0:49:52
In reply to Re: opiates and major depression, posted by androog on October 18, 2001, at 18:33:01
> It's interesting to note that I actually was taking Ultram as prescribed by my previous psychiatrist in Indiana. I had forgotten that, as I have forgotten many things, due to the ECT.Couldn't you go back to this pdoc? Isn't Indiana fairly close to Chicago?
-Neal
Posted by Peter S. on October 20, 2001, at 16:48:31
In reply to Re: opiates and major depression, posted by androog on October 19, 2001, at 23:26:35
> Hi Peter,
>
> Initially I started with the normal dose of 4oomg per day. I have taken four times that much in a day and it didn't seem to make much of a difference one way or the other in terms of my level of depression.
>
> I really should mention that I am non-practicing alcoholic who stopped drinking in 1985. I hate the term "recovering alcoholic" because it implies that an alcoholic will one day be free of the disease, which I don't think ever happens, otherwise I'd've figured out how to swing that a loooong time ago.
>
> When I was in the middle of my ECT treatments this past February, I started drinking again. This is something I never thought I'd do because I have absolutely no doubt that alcohol is something I have no control over. I don't even remember any of the drinking, but according to my wife I was going at it pretty hard. I somehow managed to quit again, but don't really remember that, either. I can't stress how much the ECT affected my memory. Well, that and the booze. It's kind of interesting that I'd show up at the hospital legally drunk, and they'd go through with the ECT regardless. Especially since they start you off with an IV of valium. Sounds like fun. Wish I could remember it.
>
> Anyway, I think the point I'm trying to make is that I'm an addictive person prone to substance abuse. It's not surprising to me that I was taking far more tramadol than I needed. When it gets right down to it I need about 800mg, or twice the recommended amount, daily to maintain an even keel. I should repeat that I told nobody but my wife that I was taking the tramadol (kind of a blind taste test), and all I heard from family and friends was how good it was to see me back to my old self. I guess what I'm getting is that i haven't become some drooling, nodding out junkie. Just a motivated and happier one.
>
> There's no doubt in my mind that my depression is at the root of my substance abuse, not the other way around. It's just a guess, but I'd say a good majority of substance abusers are suffering from some form of depression. I further believe that the reason we abuse certain substances is that we're trying to make up for something lacking in our brain chemistry - something that occurs naturally in others. I know all the talk is about serotonin, but I'd bet the house that what we substance abusers are lacking in are endorphins.
>
> Anyway, I just got a call back from the one doc I'd called earlier who sounded as though he might be willing to give the tramadol a try. In his return call he said he couldn't find enough evidence to back up my claim that opiates have been successfully used in the treatment of depression. I found this odd because it took me only a few minutes on the internet to find a study conducted by the Harvard School of Medicine that supported my claim.
>
> If anybody out there knows of any respectable websites whose findings are pro-opiate in the treatment of major depression, please let me know. I know way down deep that I'm right, at least to some degree, on this one. Of course, I've said that before and been wrong, but hey: you can't blame a feller for trying.
>
> Thanks much,
> Androog
Posted by Elizabeth on October 22, 2001, at 11:43:48
In reply to Re: opiates and major depression, posted by androog on October 19, 2001, at 23:26:35
> It's just a guess, but I'd say a good majority of substance abusers are suffering from some form of depression.
Me too; depression or anxiety, anyway. A *lot* of opioid addicts have major social anxiety, which I very much identify with. One guy said that when he's around lots of people, he feels like they look like gargoyles. And I knew what he meant (although he said it much more concisely and more clearly than I ever could).
> I know all the talk is about serotonin, but I'd bet the house that what we substance abusers are lacking in are endorphins.
I suspect it's a little more complicated than that, but yes, the endogenous opioid system is undoubtably involved in our problems. (I'm not an addict, but I think that my troubles aren't all that different from those of many -- most? -- opioid addicts, and perhaps alcoholics too.)
> Anyway, I just got a call back from the one doc I'd called earlier who sounded as though he might be willing to give the tramadol a try. In his return call he said he couldn't find enough evidence to back up my claim that opiates have been successfully used in the treatment of depression. I found this odd because it took me only a few minutes on the internet to find a study conducted by the Harvard School of Medicine that supported my claim.
A lot of the research on the subject seems to come out of Harvard, yes. Take a look at http://www.hmcnet.harvard.edu/psych/redbook/15.htm
Here are some other sites and cites:
http://www.addict.f2s.com/medarticlemenu.html
"An Addict's View -- Medical Articles." Great site. A selection of research (basic and clinical) articles relating to opioids and psych disorders.Stoll AL, Rueter S. Treatment augmentation with opiates in severe and refractory major depression. Am J Psychiatry. 1999 Dec;156(12):2017.
A clinical case series in which oxycodone and (get this) oxymorphone were used successfully as antidepressants for patients who hadn't responded to conventional treatments.Bodkin JA, Zornberg GL, Lukas SE, Cole JO. Buprenorphine treatment of refractory depression.
J Clin Psychopharmacol. 1995 Feb;15(1):49-57.
Another case series, this one using buprenorphine. You can read this one on the web: http://balder.prohosting.com/~adhpage/bupe.htmlCallaway E. Buprenorphine for depression: the un-adoptable orphan. Biol Psychiatry. 1996 Jun 15;39(12):989-90.
And here's some stuff on Ultram (some pro, some anti):
Shapira NA, Verduin ML, DeGraw JD. Treatment of refractory major depression with tramadol monotherapy. J Clin Psychiatry. 2001 Mar;62(3):205-6.
Goldsmith TB, Shapira NA, Keck PE Jr. Rapid remission of OCD with tramadol hydrochloride. Am J Psychiatry. 1999 Apr;156(4):660-1.
Spencer C. The efficacy of intramuscular tramadol as a rapid-onset antidepressant. Aust N Z J Psychiatry. 2000 Dec;34(6):1032-3.
Halfpenny DM, Callado LF, Stamford JA. Is tramadol an antidepressant? Br J Anaesth. 1999 Mar;82(3):480-1.
Markowitz JS, Patrick KS. Venlafaxine-tramadol similarities. Med Hypotheses. 1998 Aug;51(2):167-8.
Rojas-Corrales MO, Gibert-Rahola J, Mico JA. Tramadol induces antidepressant-type effects in mice. Life Sci. 1998;63(12):PL175-80.
I know there's been an article or letter somewhere that describes a case of Ultram treatment of social phobia (it might be the OCD one).
HTH
-elizabeth
Posted by androog on October 24, 2001, at 21:17:42
In reply to Re: opiates and major depression » androog, posted by Elizabeth on October 22, 2001, at 11:43:48
hi folks,
well it's been an interesting week. the pdoc who said he couldn't find enough evidence supporting my claim that ultram really eased my depression, referred me to another doc he thought might be more willing to go out on a ledge. I called this doc, but he charged $500 just to walk in the door and, of course, said he couldn't guarantee he'd try me on anything like ultram.
i got on the internet and went to my walgreen's account and discovered that prior to january 2001, two pdocs had prescribed ultram for me. this was before i had ECT and i had no recollection of it. one of the two who had previously prescribed it for me was a referral that i had gotten from my current pdoc (doc 1). i don't know if i mentioned it before, but doc 1 is strictly by-the-book, and very methodical. i had asked him about ultram numerous times before, but my request fell upon deaf ears.
anyway, i called the doc (doc 2) who had prescribed the full dose of 400mg in the past, and asked if he could give it another try, this time in conjunction with my current anti-depressants. he didn't want to go around doc 1 and suggested i give doc 1 another try and if there were any problems, to have doc 1 call him, doc 2.
confused yet? i'm not done.
i called doc 1, told him of the conversation i had had with doc 2, and much to my surprise, doc 1 said he had recently come across evidence supporting my claims about ultram.
exonerated at last! maybe.
doc 1 won't prescribe any ultram for me without my first coming in to see him. this guy has no clue as to how awful major depression is. if i had a broken leg, would he have me come in to see him in a month (that's when his next opening is)? i don't think so. i find that very few people who have never had it can appreciate the full intensity of major depression. they seem to think it's sadness, and will just eventually go away of its own accord. i think of it as being handcuffed 24 hrs a day to a terrorist. the terrorist is the voice in my head that keeps saying, "i ain't going anywhere, so you might as well just kill yourself. it'll only get worse, and anyone you tell this to will be incapable of understanding the seriousness of this threat. so just do it."
well, i've managed to get an appointment with doc 1 tomorrow by explaining the whole predicament to his very-understanding receptionist. won't he be surprised to see me so soon? he looks at the floor a lot when i talk about stuff that he's not comfortable with, such as my depression.
i'll let you all know the results of tomorrow's appointment. i'm not giving it a lot of hope. i can already see him giving me a script for 100mg a day, which just doesn't cut it. i know - i've tried. it'll take at least the full 400mg to get me back to the point where i can finally start making a living again. and, after awhile, it'll take more than that. tolerance to this type of medication is inevitable, so i'm going to keep trying to get my tramadol (ultram) overseas. it's a lot cheaper, is every bit as effective, and doesn't leave me dependent on someone who doesn't have a clue, other than an intellectual one, to the severity and relentlessness of this beast. book knowledge, yes. street smarts, no.
also, i'm going to try to get out from underneath doc 1 and start seeing doc 2 instead. it's a political quagmire since they know each other, but i think doc 2 is more tuned-in to the nastiness of major depression
thanks once again for hearing me out. i know that my whining to my wife about this eventually just starts to get her down. she's stood by me throughout this ordeal and has helped me immensely. but after awhile even the strongest of people get tired of hearing about all of this negativity. that's where a dicussion group like this can really help. thanks to you, too, dr. bob for providing this forum.
i look forward to the day when i can shutup and get back to the things i once enjoyed. and at this point, i have no qualms whatsoever about being dependent on drugs to get me there.
best of luck to all of you,
androog
Posted by Kristi on October 27, 2001, at 20:35:10
In reply to Re: opiates and major depression, posted by androog on October 24, 2001, at 21:17:42
Hi,
I'm curious how your appt. went. Did you get a prescription? Of more than 100 mg???I take Ultram myself, for pain... never really realized it was used for depression, but I guess that explains why my depression has been slightly relieved in the past few months.
Take care, Kristi
> hi folks,
>
> well it's been an interesting week. the pdoc who said he couldn't find enough evidence supporting my claim that ultram really eased my depression, referred me to another doc he thought might be more willing to go out on a ledge. I called this doc, but he charged $500 just to walk in the door and, of course, said he couldn't guarantee he'd try me on anything like ultram.
>
> i got on the internet and went to my walgreen's account and discovered that prior to january 2001, two pdocs had prescribed ultram for me. this was before i had ECT and i had no recollection of it. one of the two who had previously prescribed it for me was a referral that i had gotten from my current pdoc (doc 1). i don't know if i mentioned it before, but doc 1 is strictly by-the-book, and very methodical. i had asked him about ultram numerous times before, but my request fell upon deaf ears.
>
> anyway, i called the doc (doc 2) who had prescribed the full dose of 400mg in the past, and asked if he could give it another try, this time in conjunction with my current anti-depressants. he didn't want to go around doc 1 and suggested i give doc 1 another try and if there were any problems, to have doc 1 call him, doc 2.
>
> confused yet? i'm not done.
>
> i called doc 1, told him of the conversation i had had with doc 2, and much to my surprise, doc 1 said he had recently come across evidence supporting my claims about ultram.
>
> exonerated at last! maybe.
>
> doc 1 won't prescribe any ultram for me without my first coming in to see him. this guy has no clue as to how awful major depression is. if i had a broken leg, would he have me come in to see him in a month (that's when his next opening is)? i don't think so. i find that very few people who have never had it can appreciate the full intensity of major depression. they seem to think it's sadness, and will just eventually go away of its own accord. i think of it as being handcuffed 24 hrs a day to a terrorist. the terrorist is the voice in my head that keeps saying, "i ain't going anywhere, so you might as well just kill yourself. it'll only get worse, and anyone you tell this to will be incapable of understanding the seriousness of this threat. so just do it."
>
> well, i've managed to get an appointment with doc 1 tomorrow by explaining the whole predicament to his very-understanding receptionist. won't he be surprised to see me so soon? he looks at the floor a lot when i talk about stuff that he's not comfortable with, such as my depression.
>
> i'll let you all know the results of tomorrow's appointment. i'm not giving it a lot of hope. i can already see him giving me a script for 100mg a day, which just doesn't cut it. i know - i've tried. it'll take at least the full 400mg to get me back to the point where i can finally start making a living again. and, after awhile, it'll take more than that. tolerance to this type of medication is inevitable, so i'm going to keep trying to get my tramadol (ultram) overseas. it's a lot cheaper, is every bit as effective, and doesn't leave me dependent on someone who doesn't have a clue, other than an intellectual one, to the severity and relentlessness of this beast. book knowledge, yes. street smarts, no.
>
> also, i'm going to try to get out from underneath doc 1 and start seeing doc 2 instead. it's a political quagmire since they know each other, but i think doc 2 is more tuned-in to the nastiness of major depression
>
> thanks once again for hearing me out. i know that my whining to my wife about this eventually just starts to get her down. she's stood by me throughout this ordeal and has helped me immensely. but after awhile even the strongest of people get tired of hearing about all of this negativity. that's where a dicussion group like this can really help. thanks to you, too, dr. bob for providing this forum.
>
> i look forward to the day when i can shutup and get back to the things i once enjoyed. and at this point, i have no qualms whatsoever about being dependent on drugs to get me there.
>
> best of luck to all of you,
> androog
Posted by androog on October 28, 2001, at 14:35:18
In reply to opiates and major depression, posted by androog on October 16, 2001, at 16:49:58
Hi All,
My recent trip to my current pdoc did, indeed, yield some results. After rapping me on the knuckles for my "deceit" (not telling him that i was taking ultram on my own) he proceeded to write a script for 400mg of ultram a day. he was very angry that i had been self-medicating. of course, my telling him about my self-medicating would be akin to telling the warden that i had a nice little tunnel from which to escape my impending death sentence.i told him that i had walked the straight and narrow for over 15 years, taking only those medications prescribed to me by a doctor. after shelling out thousands of dollars seeking a solution to my problem with no results, i decided to take matters into my own hands (and will continue to do so). i told him that i felt like i had reached the end of a long corridor and was faced with 2 doors: one marked "suicide", the other "drug dependency". i told him i didn't have to think long before selecting the "drug dependency" door. he didn't care much for my analogy, probably because it only left him with the "suicide" door to recommend.
at any rate, he said he would only write the ultram prescription once a month upon my seeing him, and that there would be no refills. if he found that i was deceiving him in any way, the game was over - he was taking his ball and going home.
this was interesting to me in two ways: 1) he was writing a prescription based on MY recommendation while at the same time chastising me for taking said drug and 2) he was treating me as a common criminal for having a history of substance abuse.
i've found over the years that although major recurring depression and substance abuse have been found to have strong physiological ties, many doctors acknowledge this only superficially. inwardly they harbor the same antiquated images of a bowery bum as do many other unenlightened people.
having had a substance abuse problem for many years, i've given a lot of thought as to what might be the best course of treatment. not once has a doctor asked me what makes my natural state of conciousness so awful that i need to self-medicate. and that's basically what it gets down to. address that problem and the rest will likely take care of itself. the catch is, at least in my case, that treatment would involve the use of opiates, and that doesn't sit well with most docs. i have tried countless antidepressants over the years to no avail. opiates work almost immediately on me and leave me perfectly capable of going about my everday duties. i've tried opiates in the past without telling anyone, and have received only positive feedback concerning my ability to get things done, to socialize and to have a pleasant, sunny disposition. i don't stagger, nod out, drool, dress only in black and come out at night, or any of the other pre-conceived notions of how a drug addict behaves. there's a reason we have opiate receptors.
it is SO frustrating to me to know that there is something out there that will free me, but that our society has placed such powerful sanctions against it that one needs to become a criminal to obtain it. why should society care what i put in my body? we can place liquor. tobacco and double cheeseburgers with fries into our systems anytime we want, and well we should. but when it comes to opiates the attitude is stick 'em in prison or refer 'em to another doc.
Kristi, if taking 100mg of ultram a day relieves your depression slightly, i'd guess that 2, 3, or even 4 times that much would almost entirely eradicate it. of course, i'm not a doctor. but i have had more personal experience with the drug than do most docs. additionally there are now studies that back up my layman's hypothesis.
well, i've spewed forth yet another manifesto in defense of the more liberal use of opiates for those who find that their minds and well-being crave it.
best of luck to all who live in the pit of despair.
androog
Posted by Ed O`Flaherty on October 27, 2002, at 16:47:49
In reply to Re: opiates and major depression, posted by androog on October 18, 2001, at 18:33:01
I came across this thread to-day when I was trying to get a report on Stoll`s article on opiates in depression in the American Journal of Psychiatry published in 1999.
Ultram was mentioned in the thread and I wonder is anybody using it.It is an opiate with a reckoned low likelihood of dependence.It is widely use all over the woprld as an analgesic (tramadol),being a bit stronger than ibuprofen.
Posted by androog on October 27, 2002, at 20:04:14
In reply to Re: opiates and major depression, posted by Ed O`Flaherty on October 27, 2002, at 16:47:49
I'm the fellow that posted the initial thread concerning tramadol and depression. I've been taking the tramadol for almost a year and have been greatly helped by it. Why I had to go and do all the research and twist my doctor's arm before he findly relented to prescribing it, I'll never know.
I realize that I'm prosletyzing, but it is inconceivable to me that the stigma of addiction outweighs the likliehood of suicide in the treatment of the severely depressed. That anyone can sit on their high horse and dole out useless drug after useless drug, all the while telling the patient to come back in three to six weeks, is nothing short of malpractice in my book. If I were to go to my doctor with a compound fracture and he gave me a couple of aspirin and told me to be on my way, he would certainly be guilty of negligence. This situation is hardly different. I would expect somebody who was trained in a specialty such as psychiatry would have some sort of clue as to just how dangerous depression can be. I had repeatedly told three different psychiatrists that opiates worked for me, and got the same dull stare every time. Nobody batted an eye when it came to giving me ECT 17 times, often when I was drunk. Nobody cared much when the ECT did nothing for me other than wipe out years of memories ("there was nothing else we could do" i was told). But eyebrows certainly shot up when I brought up the subject of opiates!
It's been about a year since I posted the original thread (seems much longer than that) and I'm happy to say that tramadol has saved my life. I started taking it on my own when nobody would prescribe it for me, and would continue to do so even if I didn't have a valid prescription. My psychiatrist only prescribed it when I asked him for a referral to someone with a more open mind concerning the subject. To this day he shows little interest in it and doesn't even know what dosage it comes in. Why do I continue to go to him? Tramadol, pure and simple. I've long since given up the notion of anybody in the business (and I mean business) of psychiatry actually being useful (pardon me Dr. Bob). I'm sure there are many out there, but I haven't the time or money to go seeking them out. I pay $150 every month to get a prescription written -- a prescription I had to instruct my shrink to write. In return, I get to stay alive.
That said, I can tell you for a fact that tramadol works for at least one person with refractory depression. I have not built up a toerance to it, the side effects are negligible and increased dosages (yes, i've tried it) only make me dizzy. I would suggest its use for anybody with treatment-resistant depression.
Sorry for spewing forth like this, but as you can see, I'm very bitter about the whole experience. Major depression is a force to be reckoned with and sometimes you have to pull out the big guns to do it. Better sooner than later. Sometimes you only get one chance.
Posted by utopizen on October 27, 2002, at 21:01:58
In reply to Re: opiates and major depression, posted by Ed O`Flaherty on October 27, 2002, at 16:47:49
So, um, was I the only one freaked out after reading Confessions of an Opium Reader?
Posted by Dr. Bob on October 28, 2002, at 8:07:03
In reply to Re: opiates and major depression, posted by utopizen on October 27, 2002, at 21:01:58
> So, um, was I the only one freaked out after reading Confessions of an Opium Reader?
I'd just like to plug the new double double quote feature. But I don't mean to be pushy. Did you deliberately not use it to link to Amazon? If so, I'd be interested in why, over at PBA:
http://www.dr-bob.org/babble/admin/20020918/msgs/7717.html
Thanks,
Bob
Posted by Blah on January 21, 2003, at 10:12:54
In reply to Re: opiates and major depression, posted by androog on October 28, 2001, at 14:35:18
I'm in a similar possition to Androogs. I am 28 and have had depression/dysthymia my entire life (probably have a mix of personality disorder traits too). I started deep psycoanalasys 3 times a week when I was 5. Since high school I have tried: a triciclycate, prozac, serzone, paxil, wellbutrin, rameron, trazidone, zoloft, nardil (an MAOI), effexor, adderal, ritalin, and maybe others as well; I can't remember them all. All of these drugs not only didn't help but made things worse, and I had full trials on most of them (the side effects were just too much, most I stuck it out for 3 months to a year just to find myself deteriorating). Most times a drug doesn't work the frustrated pdocs will blame me for the failier. Once a pdoc said the drug wasn't working because I wasn't execising regularly, I explplained that because of my depression I didn't have the energy to cook meals everyday let alone exercise. Her responce was, "You have to make the energy," truely science at work.
My parents were very emotionaly abusive in weird and a typical ways. I have always had terrible problems concentrating, but have only been critisized for it, even by pdocs and some therapists. I made it through college with few friends, and no one would hire me. I now live on SSI, and my symtems are becoming worse. I haven't had a relationship in over a decade, and even masterbation means nothing to me anymore, just fills me with more hopelessness. I just fired another useless pdoc (a second year resident) who couldn't undersatand that after 23 years of useless treatment I wanted some control. Like most she cared more about her ego than me: "but I'm the Dr. I'm the one with the Phd!" At this point I feel an opioid analgisic is the only thing that will work for me. I'm always dissociating cause everything, EVERYTHING, is so painfull, I also have terrible hypervigulance. To this day I still can't ride a bicycle. I got my father to pay for a mood dissorder specialist. They said on the phone they do rx opiates. I have never done heroin or other hard drugs, I don't drink or smoke, only smoke marijauana occassionaly, and didn't do anything till I was 24; so I have no addiction history unless you want to infantalize me by claiming that using any drug at anytime is addiction, which many pdocs often do. I'll write back later to tell you all how it went.If you write back:
-no mention of ECT. It is a temporary and barbaric practice with perminant damage, and I would sooner commit suicide. Many pdocs and therapist have said it wouldn't work for me anyway.-no mention of other SSRIs I haven't tryed like Celexa. It is obvious this class of drugs is harmful for me, and I see no reason to enter into it again.
Sorry if this sounds rude but I am tired of the same useless advice being doled out by the robots of psychiatry.
-Blah
Posted by BrittPark on January 21, 2003, at 11:14:05
In reply to Re: opiates and major depression, posted by Blah on January 21, 2003, at 10:12:54
I'm sorry you're having a rough time. Before you see your new psychiatrist, do some research on opioids and depression both on the web in general and in the PB archives. The research on opioids for treating depression is sparse but there. The two opioids for which there is some research are buprenorphine and tramadol.
I'm a strong believer in the use of opioids for depression. If it weren't for the spectre of tolerance opioids would be perfect ADs for many people (including me).
Good Luck and Feel Better,
Britt
Posted by androog on January 21, 2003, at 13:29:13
In reply to Re: opiates and major depression, posted by Blah on January 21, 2003, at 10:12:54
Hi All,
Androog here. I wanted to let you know some interesting things about tramadol and how it has worked with my depression. Bear in mind that my memory has some gaping holes in it from the ECT I had done 2 years ago. I still don't retain info very well, so I apologize if I repeat myself in this post.
First, I should mention that I am a recovering alcohoic ( I hate that term -- sounds like I'll recover some day and be able to drink resonsibly). I have also been through the drug ringer with regards to my chemical dependency.
Second, the fact that I have this history of chemical dependence has raised a red flag with every pdoc I have ever seen. They shudder at the thought of giving someone like me a potentially addictive drug. They don't shudder at the mention of suicide, which is apparently preferable to chemical dependence, as is frying your brain with ECT.
That said, I 'm happy to report that in the almost two years that I have been taking tramadol my intake has actually dropped. In fact, I am taking only about half of what I was taking a year ago.
This is interesting to me because addiction usually (always?) involves an increased tolerance of the addictive substance. This has not been my experience with tramadol.I must admit that in the past I have tried taking more tramadol than I really need. Once an addict always an addict. The result of the excessive tramadol intake on me has been negative -- dizziness and disorientation rather than the euphoria I would have expected. This has worked in my favor because I no longer take more than I need. The tramadol seems to have a fail-safe mechanism built into it to foil my addictive tendencies. It's a great relief to me to know that I won't have to keep increasing my dosage -- not because I'm that concerned about addiction, but because of the lack of availability of the tramadol. Addiction can be reversed, suicide cannot.
With regards to Blah's experience with pdocs, I have had the same thing happen over and over. It has become clear to me that the vast majority of those who treat major depression have never experienced it. They say "Take this drug and see me in 3 weeks". This is akin to saying "Take aspirin for 3 weeks and we'll see if that relieves the pain of your compound fracture". It's nothing short of cruelty, but in an ignorant sort of way.
Blah, people like us have to accept the fact that the severity of our disease is something most pdocs only read about. Problem is, words don't begin to describe the horror of major depression, so unless they've experienced it firsthand, they'll only know what they read in a book or hear from their patients. Try describing sight to a person who has been blind since birth. It's not much different than what we go through with our pdocs.
I have no idea, of course, if tramadol will work for everyone. It probably won't. I also don't know what kind of pysical toll, if any, it has taken on my body. Only time will tell.
What I do know is that if it had not been for the tramadol I would probably not be here to write this. I figure I have lived at least a year longer than I would have without it, so any injurious effects I've experienced from it are, in my mind, offset by my increased longevity and quality of life.
I'm not a physician and I 'm operating solely on the basis of my experience, but ignorance coupled with experience is better than ignorance alone, and the treatment I was receiving involved only ignorance.
Blah, don't do something rash while there are still options open to you, even if those options are unorthodox. I never thought I'd feel okay again when I was in the pit of despair, yet here I am writing this post when I should be working ;>)
I know how awful you feel and how scared you can get when you start to believe that suicide is the only answer. Words ring hollow when you're hurting like you must be, but I'll use 'em anyhow. Something will work for you, and your depression is NOT your fault. Call around and see if there is a pdoc in your area that is willing to use tramadol or opiates to treat depression. That's what I did, and I was surprised at the response.
Hang in there, Blah!
Androog
Posted by juanantoniod on January 22, 2003, at 1:27:44
In reply to Re: opiates and major depression » Blah, posted by androog on January 21, 2003, at 13:29:13
Hi, Androog!
I agree with almost everything you've said and been through. I would just like to know if you take your Ultram in divided doses and if so, how often, or in one daily dose?
Best wishes,
Antonio
Posted by djmmm on January 22, 2003, at 8:42:35
In reply to Re: opiates and major depression , posted by juanantoniod on January 22, 2003, at 1:27:44
For what it's worth, tramadol's major pharmalogical effects are mediated through serotonin and norepinephrine reuptake. It only has minor effects on the opioid system. It is very similar to Effexor.
Posted by BrittPark on January 22, 2003, at 11:11:49
In reply to Re: opiates and major depression , posted by djmmm on January 22, 2003, at 8:42:35
> For what it's worth, tramadol's major pharmalogical effects are mediated through serotonin and norepinephrine reuptake. It only has minor effects on the opioid system. It is very similar to Effexor.
IIRC, tramadol's analgesic effect is about 50/50 opioid/catecholamine. In animal studies naloxone reverses about 50% of its analgesic effect.
Tramadol itself binds very poorly to opiate receptors but it 0-desmethyl metabolite binds much more strongly, though still relatively weekly.Now as to its mechanism as an AD it may well be NE/5-HT that's the key. But I'm betting that it is also the opiate receptor activity.
Cheers,
Britt
Posted by androog on January 22, 2003, at 13:37:17
In reply to Re: opiates and major depression , posted by juanantoniod on January 22, 2003, at 1:27:44
Hi Everyone,
I need to correct a statement I made on my last post. In that post I said that I didn't develop a tolerance to tramadol. My wife reminded me that when I first started taking tramadol for my depression about 2 years ago I only needed 150 mg. I DID develop a tolerance to normal doasages of the tramadol. I kept taking more to get the desired effect. When I got up to 800 mg I hit a plateau. That was back in late 2001, and I still respond to that amount. I realize that that is twice the recommended daily dose, but that's what it takes to get me out of my pit, and the pit is somewhere I'm not going to again, if I can help it.
I take an initial dose of 600 mg and then spread the other 200 mg out over the rest of the day.
About 50 minutes after I take the initial dose I start to feel the depression lift.
About 1 hour after I take my first dose, I get a brief feeling of euphoria or something close to it. This lasts perhaps 5-10 minutes, after that I just feel ok -- no euphoria, no depression. I have to wonder if the euphoria part is really just a feeling of normalcy that seems exaggerated because it eradicates the hell of depression so quickly. Or maybe it's the weak opioid mechanism at work. Could be that's why it takes so much to get me there. But that doesn't explain why the same dose every day has the same effect it did over a year-and-a-half ago.
It's certainly possible that a pure opiod would stop my depression with a smaller dose, but the very word "opioid" elicits a knee-jerk response from the docs I mention it to. I'd like to give opioids a go, but I can't find a doc that'll go that route.
One more thing I neglected to mention is that I also take 200 mg of the tricyclic doxepin a day. This alone doesn't do anything, but it probably enhances the effect of the tramadol. I've read that tramadol can increase the serotonin-raising effects of antidepressants.
I think that's it for now.
Take care, and don't give up the ship.
androog
Posted by androog on January 22, 2003, at 13:54:59
In reply to Re: opiates and major depression » djmmm, posted by BrittPark on January 22, 2003, at 11:11:49
Exercise really does help. I've been a regular exerciser for about 17 years. I fitness-walk for at least 30 mins. a day 5 or more days of the week. 10 minutes or so after I excercise my mood goes up another notch.
Like Blah, when I was suicidal it was next to impossible to get myself to exercise. The few times I tried it, it didn't help.
Laying an exercise guilt trip on an already depressed individual only adds fuel to the fire and indicates a lack of understanding of the depths of depression on the part of whomever is laying on the guilt trip.
I recommend exercise, but don't find fault in a person who is unable to do it. After all, even the majority of Americans who are NOT depressed can't seem to bring themselves to exercise.
androog
Posted by jrbecker on January 22, 2003, at 23:01:37
In reply to ps, posted by androog on January 22, 2003, at 13:54:59
I've never responded well to most traditional ADs either. If you ever do find an opitate-friendly doc in the Chicagoland area, I would like to know about him/her as well.
Would appreciate it if you could drop me a line if that ever happens:
good luck with everything.
Posted by Blah on January 23, 2003, at 7:33:49
In reply to opiates and major depression » androog, posted by jrbecker on January 22, 2003, at 23:01:37
> I've never responded well to most traditional ADs either. If you ever do find an opitate-friendly doc in the Chicagoland area, I would like to know about him/her as well.
>
> Would appreciate it if you could drop me a line if that ever happens:
>
> jrbecker76@hotmail.com
>
If you could send me some names too that would be good. I am also in the chicago area. On the phone these new Pdocs seem opioid friendly, but my distrust of doctors has grown so strong I'm not counting on it. We'll find out today.You can send any info to:
Thanks
Blah
Posted by androog on January 23, 2003, at 11:11:34
In reply to Re: opiates and major depression, posted by Blah on January 23, 2003, at 7:33:49
Wow!
Thank you to those who have responded to my previous posts so positively. I kind of expected to be skinned alive for my views on opiates. Instead, people have been very supportive.
I thought I should mention that I have stopped looking for a sympathetic pdoc. I found one that'll write a prescription for tramadol (Ultram) and I'm just going to stick with him. Oddly enough, I decided to stay with him because he basically stays out of my way and doesn't try to anything new. At this point, his only function as far as I'm concerned is as a prescription-writer. After many years of trying different antidepressants and ECT, I realized I was pouring a lot of money into a pretty inaffective sries of treatments and getting nowhere but broke. That's why I have taken my treatment into my own hands.
For better or worse, I'm going to do what it takes to keep myself off the road to suicide.
And now the fine print:
Please remember that I'm not qualified to dispense medical advice. I'm only saying what has worked for me and am not trying to convince anyone to take tramadol or opiates. We all respond differently to medications. Ultram mixed with standard antidepressants can have serious consequences, from what I've read. I took a chance and it worked for me. But what works for me could possibly kill someone else.androog
Posted by BrittPark on January 23, 2003, at 11:28:55
In reply to Re: opiates and major depression, posted by androog on January 23, 2003, at 11:11:34
The most dangerous outcome from tramadol use is seizures. In general tramadol seems to increase the likelihood of seizures 2-6 fold. That may sound like a lot but remember that original likelihood of seizures is quite low. Those who are taking certain antidepressants (TCAs eg) that lower the seizure threshold are somewhat more at risk but I haven't been able to find a number. I would advise caution.
Here are some Medline Abstracts
Tramadol and seizures: a surveillance study in a managed care population.
Gardner JS, Blough D, Drinkard CR, Shatin D, Anderson G, Graham D, Alderfer R.
Department of Pharmacy, University of Washington, Seattle 98195, USA.
STUDY OBJECTIVE: To investigate the occurrence of tramadol-associated seizures. DESIGN: Retrospective cohort and case-control studies. SETTING: UnitedHealth Group-affiliated independent practice model health plans, from different regions of the United States, contracting with large networks of physicians. INTERVENTION: Analysis of administrative data from a large U.S. managed care population. PATIENTS: A cohort of 9218 adult tramadol users and 37,232 concurrent nonusers. MEASUREMENTS AND MAIN RESULTS: Fewer than 1% of users (80) had a presumed incident seizure claim after the first tramadol prescription. Risk of seizure claim was increased 2- to 6-fold among users adjusted for selected comorbidities and concomitant drugs. Risk was highest among those aged 25-54 years, those with more than four tramadol prescriptions, and those with history of alcohol abuse, stroke, or head injury. A case-control study among users was conducted to validate incident seizure outcomes from medical records. Only eight cases were confirmed, and all had cofactors associated with increased seizure risk. CONCLUSION: In a general population, risk of seizure may be associated with long-term therapy with tramadol or the presence of cofactors, or confined to a small sensitive population subset.
Incidence of first-time idiopathic seizures in users of tramadol.Gasse C, Derby L, Vasilakis-Scaramozza C, Jick H.
Department of Clinical Pharmacology and Pharmacoepidemiology, University Hospital Heidelberg, Germany.
STUDY OBJECTIVE: To assess the risk of idiopathic incident seizures among patients who ever took tramadol. DESIGN: Nested case-control design. SETTING: General Practice Research Database from November 1996-August 1998. PATIENTS: Eleven thousand three hundred eighty-three patients. INTERVENTION: Comparison of risks of idiopathic incident seizures during exposed and unexposed times among patients who had ever taken tramadol and other analgesics with 90-day follow-up. MEASUREMENTS AND MAIN RESULTS: Among the 11,383 subjects we identified 21 cases of idiopathic seizures, 10 of which were categorized as definite cases and 11 categorized as possible cases. Three patients were exposed to tramadol alone in the previous 90 days, 10 to opiates, three to both tramadol and opiates, one to other analgesics, and four to no analgesics. CONCLUSION: The risk of idiopathic seizures was similarly elevated in each analgesic exposure category compared with nonusers, suggesting that the risk for patients taking tramadol was not increased compared with other analgesics.
Whatever it takes,
Britt
Posted by androog on January 23, 2003, at 14:43:25
In reply to Re: opiates and major depression » androog, posted by BrittPark on January 23, 2003, at 11:28:55
Hi Britt,
Thank you so much for the unbiased scientific info on tramadol. I've been trying to find out more about it, but I have no science background and haven't met with much success.
I'd read that there was an increased risk of seizures in people who take the stuff, but that was about it.
This info enables me, and other people in the same boat, to make a more informed decision regarding its use.
I've had 17 ETC-induced seizures, but I still know next to nothing about seizures.What exactly occurs when one has a grand mal seizure? Is there brain damage? Does it always interefere with memory?
Thanks
androog
Posted by Blah on January 23, 2003, at 22:40:06
In reply to Re: opiates and major depression, posted by androog on January 23, 2003, at 14:43:25
Hi Androog and all:
I saw the mood disorder specialist today, and even though the first visit is $345 not much happened. He said he wouldn't give me an opioid analgesic untill I tried some mood stabalizers and antipsycotics. I'm willing to do that, but he was not willing to say how many I had to try before we could rule them out and move on to opiates. It would be great if one of them worked, but after all the "wonder drugs" I tried just to have them make me worse I don't have a lot of trust left.
What's worse is he wants me to go into the hospital for a month or more so I can try more more quickly, but if I do that he still won't commit to a time when I could switch to an opioid if they didn't work. I can't try every mood stabalizer and antipsycotic. Once you try 2 or 3 drugs from a certain school you cancel that school out; to try them all is a waste of time and abuse of the body. I'm not sure what to do I'd go in the hospital if I knew that he'd rx opioids if nothing worked but he's making it clear he'll wait as long as he can to do that, and my mental and ecconomic situation requires me to get better now. In a few years I won't get supplemental money from my mother, and Bush could easily kill SSI (social security disability) even sooner. Emotionaly I have no hope left, and today I thought about suicide maybe more serious than I ever have. I have no hope or passion left, for anything. Yet this doctor still won't give me some kind of assurance that opioids could be used soon if nothing works. I'm not sure what to do.ANDROOG, I may need to do the internet ordering. xxx Is it better to buy a cheap membership to one of those low price ones, or buy from the ones with regular prices but with no membership. xxx Also, can you get arrested for doing this , should I not use my credit card, and is it safe to have it shipped to my home.
Thanks
Blah
Posted by BrittPark on January 24, 2003, at 11:31:42
In reply to Re: opiates and major depression, posted by androog on January 23, 2003, at 14:43:25
Seizures are sudden firings of a large number of neurons in the brain. They manifest themselve in many ways: from a short blackout, to a grand mal seizure in which all the muscles in the body tense and untense. Most seizures are not dangerous but some can cause breathing to stop and lead to death. The other danger of course is that seizures can occur at dangerous moments, such as driving a car.
Perhaps someone with more expertise could comment further.
Cheers,
Britt
Go forward in thread:
Psycho-Babble Medication | Extras | FAQ
Dr. Bob is Robert Hsiung, MD,
bob@dr-bob.org
Script revised: February 4, 2008
URL: http://www.dr-bob.org/cgi-bin/pb/mget.pl
Copyright 2006-17 Robert Hsiung.
Owned and operated by Dr. Bob LLC and not the University of Chicago.