Posted by Karen44 on December 14, 2006, at 16:20:16
In reply to Re: ECT experience/Linkage, posted by stargazer on December 13, 2006, at 10:43:57
> I agree with Linkage with being able to evaluate statistics and the like.
>
> ECT outcomes vary wildly...some are helped, some are not, but it all is really subjective. I think anything as drastic as ECT can get you out of a depression since it is so physcially traumatic. But I also think the right drugs given in the right amounts can do this too without as much damage. Finding a doctor that can do this is the problem. There are not enough "experts" in psychopharm, and there should be since there are too many meds for most pdocs to get a handle on.
>
> If you are a high functioning individual, I wonder how many of those people can return to the work they were doing before ECT. It's just to hard to quantify outcomes.
>
> The best outcome I saw with ECT was on a comatose individual who did recover and return to her previous life, but she had MR and was not in a working situation.
>
> Most people I saw having ECT were not working, they were too sick. Personally I think some of the work they did made them sick, but that's another theory of mine.
>
> Stargazerthe problem for me is that my doctor is an expert in psychopharm and is still advising ect. i have taken every type of antidepressant made without help. i am on my last chance with ensam. i took parnate and it did not work as it did 20 some years ago. so, what to do. sorry for the poor typing. i had surgery on my right hand tuesday and have only one hand.
karen44
poster:Karen44
thread:711494
URL: http://www.dr-bob.org/babble/20061212/msgs/713683.html