Posted by TR on May 20, 2003, at 11:15:56
In reply to Parnate vs. Effexor: must decide in 24 hours!, posted by GregZ on May 20, 2003, at 9:28:31
Besides Parnate, the only med combination I've ever tried which has had any noticeable impact upon my depression was a combo of Effexor and Abilify (though the effect pooped out pretty fast). For me, Parnate is unequaled in its ability to alleviate my depression, but I think Effexor is a good second choice.
> Hi, I'm new to the group. I have pretty severe social anxiety (possibly avoidant personality disorder), plus a long-standing mild depression that has been with me nearly constantly for ten years (I am now 26).
>
> I did some research into medications and decided I wanted to take Parnate. I had three reasons. Parnate is said to be good for (1) people who haven't responded to other antidepressants, (2) people with social anxiety, and (3) people with atypical depression. And I fall into all three of those categories.
>
> I went in to see a nurse yesterday as a preliminary step before my seeing a psychiatrist tomorrow. I told the nurse my reasons for wanting to take Parnate. He said that I could always request Parnate, but recommended that I consider Effexor instead. Now I have 24 hours to think it over before I make up my mind.
>
> I am still uncertain but am leaning in favor of taking Parnate due to the reasons I mentioned above. When I read about Effexor yesterday, no similar reasons compelled me. But I want to ask the opinion and experiences of other people here.
>
> A little further information on me: I took Paxil in 1998, not as directed (I was stupid and took 80 mg a day), which made me manic. After the mania wore off, my depression and other problems returned, and I have not responded to any antidepressnats since then (I've tried Paxil, Serzone, and Zoloft). Hence my need to take a non-SSRI this time.
>
> Well, I managed to say all that without writing a book, so I should be pleased and quit while I'm ahead, I think... I'd really appreciate any feedback you might have to give!
>
> Greg
poster:TR
thread:227857
URL: http://www.dr-bob.org/babble/20030520/msgs/227874.html