Posted by Janice on May 10, 2000, at 12:08:58
In reply to Re: You Just Don't Get It Janice, posted by fred on May 9, 2000, at 22:22:08
Janice the issue is FORCED treatment.
•Fred, your issue is forced treatment.I was responding to Nancy's thread about her school paper. I thought she had better hear another opinion of ECT, other than the one you gave her. The issue of the thread was not forced treatment or your personal experience. Maybe you should start a new thread?
ECT is also still controversial outside the mental health industry.
•If ECT is still controversial outside the medical community, it's probably because they are not educated about it.
Lobotomies are also being done and possibly should be done for people who threaten murder and generally blame their violent behaviour on "seizures or illnesses".
•If this is happening, please go out there and stop it Fred, but don't treat anyone the way you've treated me, they'd never listen to you!
You are a victimizer not a victim.
•I am neither victimizer nor victum. The world I live in is not this black and white.
No wonder you can't understand.
•You have no idea what I can and can't understand.
It's about individuals NOT generalities.It's about the value of ANY innocent human life, not your insensitivity to my personal experience.
•Sometimes you have to generalize to get anything said. You sure did when you were critisizing me! Maybe you should try stepping back and looking at the big picture every once in a while.
It's your opinion and your shame.
•You honestly don't have any idea about my opinions.
Considering how rude you've been, I most likely won't respond to anymore of your postings. Yes, I imagine, forced treatment would be a terrible experience. I' m sorry anyone has had to experience this.
Janice
poster:Janice
thread:32651
URL: http://www.dr-bob.org/babble/20000508/msgs/33054.html