Posted by Adam on December 20, 1999, at 2:41:45
In reply to Re: Selegiline Expertise Needed Again(Long/Boring), posted by Judy on December 19, 1999, at 12:48:02
Hey, Judy,
Perhaps what a big-time psychopharm. could do for you is help you find a way to
tolerate Nardil. It seems like edema and constipation (if I'm reading your post
correctly) out to be treatable. I have had such a good response to selegiline
(for depression, at least) that I often have to restrain myself from telling everyone
and anyone who hasn't responded to five or six "first-line" antidepressant trials
to run out and get some. As you stated yourself, the lag in response is a bit
dissapointing, given the frequent rapidity of a robust MAOI response. I can only
hope that sticking it out or an augmentation strategy will help you with selegiline.
Take care and let us know how its going.
> Jeez you guys! Look at the times you're posting! And I'm moaning about MY sleep problems!!!
>
> >Can you share with us your history? I bet some good ideas will come up.
>
> Let me start by telling you that I AM an MAOI responder. I could be the 'poster child' for Nardil. I've taken it five times over the past 15 years and I am the best possible person I could ever be when taking it. Unfortunately, the side effects (severe edema, almost complete shutdown of my entire excretory system) have eliminated it from my list of possibilities. I've lost my 'safety net'! It's also probably unfortunate that Nardil is the yardstick by which I measure all other AD's because I don't think I will ever find another that provides the robust, wonderful hypomanic benefits that Nardil does.
>
> >I think I remember reading that 80mg was the maximum dose of selegiline used in depression
>
> I've never seen 80 mentioned before - but I wonder what 80 would do to my nightmarish sleep if it's bad at 60 mg.
>
> >Only the experts or the brave would augment the maoi.
>
> You're right! My Pdoc is self-admittedly not one of the brave. He would augment with lithium, however. He also admits that he's not sophisticated enough to recommend drug cocktails and would prefer that I see a big-time psychopharm in Boston for that.
>
> >If you are going from black to blue, that could be a good sign. You are, at least, maybe,
> a partial responder, which could mean that a) you will contiune to improve, or b) you have a good chance of responding to an augmentation strategy such as the addition of low-dose lithium. Non-responders to MAOI treatment are less likely to achieve a full response from lithium augmentation.
> >If you can, you might want to stay with the 60mg for another full 2 or 3 weeks
>
> This is the unknown that bothers me...am I a responder to Selegiline, obviously a completely different drug than Nardil? Nardil showed benefit within the first two weeks - is it possible that Selegiline could possibly kick-in after so much longer? Or is from 'black' to 'blue' as good as it's ever going to get? With or without augmentation? Tough questions to answer when a drug has little or no track record.
>
> >I seem to be barely dreaming at all. A this point, the insomnia is more than an equitable trade for the despair that preceeded it
>
> Not dreaming, for me, is a sign that an MAOI is working. I too missed dreaming when I took Nardil; but like you, I felt the insomnia and lack of dreams were well worth it for the relief it provided. My hellish nights right now are making me very concerned about Selegiline's effectiveness.
>
> >Maybe if you give us a history of your diagnosis, treatment, doses, reasons for discontinuing, etc.
>
> My Dx is, and I quote, "Major Depression at worst; Severe Dysthymia my best"
>
> TCA's tried: Imiprimine, Desiprimine - very little AD benefit, big weight gain, severe sweating.
>
> SSRI's: Tried all but Celexa. No AD benefit. Every one made me too fatigued to function. No amount of time made them tolerable.
>
> Effexor: Little AD benefit, too enervating
>
> Effexor SR: A disaster (for 6 weeks at 150 mg). No AD benefit. Tremors, muscle weakness. Flu-like symptoms.
>
> Klonapin: Fatigue. No benefit.
>
> Welbutrin: Way too enervating! Felt like a 'nervous breakdown' Couldn't give it a decent trial.
>
> Lithium (alone): Fatigue bordering on Coma
>
> Serzone: Worse fatigue than Lithium (if possible), with aggression and hostility from out of the blue. If I'd had the physical strength, I would have thrown myself in front of a bus to put an end to the way it made me feel!
>
> Marplan: AD benefit (nothing like Nardil though). Slower kick-in than Nardil. Worse edema.
>
> Parnate: Too enervating. Very short trial.
>
> ECT & Rememon: Both have been offered. I feel as if ECT is only a temporary measure with no medicinal backup. Remeron - after my debacle with Serzone, the thought of taking it scares the heck out of me (Can I believe that it becomes enervating at high doses?)
>
> There are more that don't come to mind right now - I wish I'd written them all down over the years. Combining any of the above really makes me skittish - like trying to make a 'right' with two 'wrong's' I do wonder if Parnate might be worth another shot if I augmented it with something (what?) to counteract the aggitation it causes.
>
> One other question. I am scheduled to have a thyroid function test done right after the holidays. I'm also wondering whether diminishing Estrogen (I'm guessing menopause isn't too far away) might be the cause of drugs that I've taken before acting differently now (i.e. Effexor was a relatively benign drug several years ago - SR almost did me in a few months ago. And the increased edema with Nardil recently? - it was never that bad before).
>
> Thanks for your responses and anything else you might be able to add. Judy
>
>
>
>
>
>
poster:Adam
thread:17103
URL: http://www.dr-bob.org/babble/19991212/msgs/17167.html